By Diane Weber Bederman ——Bio and Archives--August 27, 2015
American Politics, News | CFP Comments | Reader Friendly | Subscribe | Email Us
The surprise revelation of Argentina’s enrichment program was one of history’s most ‘startling and dismaying failures of intelligence gathering,’ according to a report published by the U.S. Department Energy. The threat of potential similar intelligence failures in Iran is driving concern among policy makers who want to prevent a secret Iranian breakout from its commitments and a race to nuclear weapons.”So I am left questioning how any Jew -- left, right, centre, Orthodox, Conservative, Reform, egalitarian, Reconstructionist, agnostic or secular -- could ever believe that this deal is good for anyone in the West, not just Israel. I think there’s something else at play. Something more sinister that’s a throwback to the attacks against Jews over the millenia. A re-working of the Spanish Inquisition. The questioning of Jewish loyalty. Jewish Americans are being asked about their loyalty. Are you a loyal citizen to the USA or are you more loyal to Israel. I have been told that these questions are asked at the government level. Can you imagine the fear this must engender in many of our Jewish leaders? If not overtly, then somewhere deep in their psyche — memories of past interrogations, persecutions and prosecutions? It’s bad enough that Jewish students on American campuses are questioned about their ability to be on campus council. At the University of California, Rachel Beyda, a second-year economics major who wanted a position on the council’s Judicial Board (like the Supreme Court) was asked by Fabienne Roth, a member of the Undergraduate Students Association Council, Given that you are a Jewish student and very active in the Jewish community how do you see yourself being able to maintain an unbiased view?” Other council members involved in the questioning were Sofia Moreno Haq, Negeen Sadeghi-Movahed and Manjot Singh. They were all concerned her faith and affiliation with Jewish organizations, including her sorority and Hillel, would affect her ability to be impartial. Were they questioned on their ability to be bias free? While the American government is questioning the loyalty of Jews, I don’t know if they are questioning the loyalty of Muslims: Will they defend western culture or Sharia Law? Or how about Catholics? Wait, America went through that prior to the election of John F. Kennedy as President. But the Jews…well…the Jews. This question of loyalty of Jewish Americans by the American government is despicable. First of all, if there were a war between America and Israel, one of these countries would have gone over to the dark side and America would have bigger problems. More important, though, is the fact that America is the recipient of the ethic that the Jewish people brought out of the desert into the light. Now the Jewish people, finally home, legally, in their native land, are thriving despite being surrounded by barbaric tribal warfare. They are implementing the very ethic that underpins Western culture, and yet, the American administration is questioning the loyalty of Jews in America. This is anti-Semitism in one of its most vile incarnations.
View Comments
Diane Weber Bederman is a blogger for ‘Times of Israel’, a contributor to Convivium, a national magazine about faith in our community, and also writes about family issues and mental illness. She is a multi-faith endorsed hospital trained chaplain.