By Bruce Deitrick Price ——Bio and Archives--February 23, 2010
American Politics, News | CFP Comments | Reader Friendly | Subscribe | Email Us
“I am desperate for help, advice, or a solution! I have a student who is in 2nd grade. He repeated 1st grade due to his reading inability. He turned 9 last fall. He's a straight A student in all subjects, except reading. He struggles with sight words above the primer level. He can fly through pre-primer and primer words in a flash, yet if you take four or five of those same words--even the exact same cards--and lay them out in a sentence form, it's as though it is a foreign language to him. After his first year in first grade, his parent had his vision tested and he did have a vision problem, even underwent vision therapy. His parents work with him at home, yet he simply cannot put it all together enough to read fluently....Anyone have any ideas that can help me help him? It is really wearing on his self-esteem.”This pattern is very common now. A child is reportedly above average in every way...except this one little thing called reading. Invariably, such children have been taught with sight-words. This poor kid, it seems to me, is a victim of child abuse. The parents must suffer daily with the belief that their son is defective. This teacher was clearly miseducated in some goofy teachers college, an intellectual ghetto from which Flesch had been banished. This teacher is teaching sight-words EVEN AFTER massive failure spread over several years. Flesch wrote his book to stop exactly this scenario; but there it is, today. Don Potter, phonics expert, gives us a sweeping picture of what the anti-Flesch forces have managed to achieve:
“The situation is dramatically worse that anyone can possibly imagine. When I ask the teachers why they teach sight-words, they inevitably tell me because their students are going to be assessed on them. They are totally unaware that sight-words are positively harmful. They consider sight-words part of a good reading program that includes some phonics, not realizing that sight-words create a reflex that interferes with phonics instruction. Sight-words are an obstacle to reading, not an aid.”Now do you have some sense of why Flesch was one lonely G.I. Joe trying to subdue a Panzer Division? Finally, consider the vast apparatus that makes all this craziness possible. For convenience we call that apparatus the Education Establishment. There’s little good you can say about these people, other than that by being so obtuse and rigid, they have made Flesch look smarter and better as the years go by. (NB: From what I understand, Canadian offcials have been more rigidly committed to sight-words than American officials. I’m convinced that these commissars, on both side of the border, have been able to keep sight-words in play for so long ONLY because book-reading adults, complacently literate for a decade or two, can’t begin to grasp what sight-words demand of a child. I’ve written a number of articles that try to put adults in the child’s place. Please see “40: Sight Words--The Big Stupid” on Improve-Education.org. For more articles about reading, see “42: Reading Resources.”)
View Comments
Bruce Deitrick Price has been writing about education for 30 years. He is the founder of Improve-Education.org. His eighth book is “Saving K-12—What happened to our public schools? How do we fix them?” More aggressively than most, Price argues that America’s elite educators have deliberately aimed for mediocrity—low standards in public schools prove this. Support this writer on Patreon.