By David C. Jennings ——Bio and Archives--August 11, 2013
World News | CFP Comments | Reader Friendly | Subscribe | Email Us
“The protection and promotion of the well-being of Scotland’s children and our aim of making our nation the best place for children to grow up are at heart of the Children and Young People Bill. Our focus is on the safety and protection of children. The named person, who is likely to be a health visitor, head or deputy head teacher and will usually already know the child, will be a first point of contact if help is needed. This is formalising what should already happen and there is evidence it is working well in many areas. We are confident it is compliant with European law.”The idea that this is ‘what should already happen’ is very alarming. Clearly the SNP sees the state, rather than the family as the appropriate and best positioned to decide the welfare of a Scottish child. There may be instances where a child needs a person they can go to, but its better in those exceptional circumstances that a team approach is employed with children being taught that they can share with teachers and doctors who can act if the circumstances warrant. This all encompassing method is a typical governmental blanket approach that is wide-open to abuse as activist types try to wrest decision making from parents under the guise that the state knows what’s best. On the Scottish Law Society’s website Morag Driscoll said:
"The policy aims behind this legislation are admirable and we recognise the genuine effort to improve the lives of children and young people in Scotland. However, we are not convinced that this legislation achieves those aims. The proposals could interfere with Article 8 of ECHR (European Court of Human Rights), the right to respect for private and family life, as there is scope for interference between the role of the 'named person' and the exercise of a parent's rights and responsibilities. It could be interpreted as disproportionate state interference. We are also unclear about how this legislation will work in practice and in particular, the resources required to administer the 'named person' scheme. We all want law that is clear, proportionate and enforceable. It is still early in the parliamentary process for this legislation so we hope the Scottish Government and MSPs will be able to reflect on these points."And the process will take time as all parliamentary legislation in the UK does. We can only pray that less controlling heads will prevail and a majority of parliamentary members will see this as a massive, intrusive and unnecessary over-step.
View Comments
David Jennings is an ex-pat Brit. living in California.
A Christian Minister he advocates for Traditional & Conservative causes.
David is also an avid fan of Liverpool Football Club and writes for the supporters club in America
David Jennings can be found on Twitter
His blog can be read here