WhatFinger

Call the waaaahhhhmbulance

WaPo sob story of the year: Muslim doctor loved his new city . . . until it voted for Trump



The Washington Post clearly intended this story as a demonstration of how awful Donald Trump supporters are. I don't think they accomplished that goal. I think they accomplished the opposite. But I doubt they're self-aware enough to realize that. The story concerns a doctor named Ayaz Virji, who is Muslim, and who recently moved to the town of Dawson, Minnesota and liked it very much. He liked the community. He liked the people he met. He felt welcome. It seemed like the sort of place where he could stay and be happy.
This sounds like the start of a story we can all feel good about, right? Well yes. And it should have stayed that way. But it didn't - not because the people of Dawson turned bad or stopped being nice to Ayaz. No. What they did that he couldn't accept was vote for Donald Trump:
And that was how it was going in Dawson, even through an election season that Ayaz found increasingly disturbing, as Trump kept whipping up crowds by saying that maybe Syrian refugees were part of a secret army, and maybe he’d have to shut down mosques, and maybe Muslims were the one immigrant group that could not become fully American. All of that was in the air, but in a county that Barack Obama had won twice, Ayaz saw only two “Trump-Pence” yard signs during the whole campaign. He never thought Trump would win, much less in Dawson. The morning after the election, he was shocked and angry, and when he looked up the local results before he went to work, the feelings only intensified. Not only had Trump won the county, he had won Dawson itself by six percentage points.

By the time he got to the hospital, he was pacing up and down the hallways, saying he hoped people realized that they just voted to put his family on a Muslim registry, and how would he be treated around here if he didn’t have “M.D.” after his name? People tried to reason with him. A colleague told him it’s not that people agreed with everything Trump said, and Ayaz said no, you’re giving them a pass. He told the hospital’s chief executive that he was thinking of resigning, and she told him to take some days to cool off. He and Musarrat talked about what to do. He began investigating a job in Dubai. He spoke to his brother in Florida, an investment adviser, who had received a fax after the election that read, “Get the f--- out of my country you Muslim pig,” and was moving to Canada. Musarrat kept thinking about the time after Sept. 11 when a man had chased her with a baseball bat, yelling about her headscarf. Nothing like that had happened in Dawson, but the Virjis began feeling differently about the town. They wondered whether the people who had seemed so warm were secretly harboring hateful thoughts or suspicions about them. Musarrat told Ayaz that she noticed more silence from certain friends. Ayaz was stopped on a sidewalk by a woman who said, “Jesus loves you,” and wondered what would happen if he said, “Muhammad loves you.” Another day, he ran into a patient who told him that a lot of farmers had voted for Trump because of sky-high health insurance premiums, not because of “anything racial,” and please, no one wants you to go. Ayaz wasn’t sure whether to believe that. But he and Musarrat decided to stay, at least for the time being, and he tried to transform his anger into understanding. Maybe people really didn’t know, he told himself. Maybe people were suffering in ways he didn’t understand.

Support Canada Free Press

Donate

Someone is being prejudiced and judgmental here. And it's not the people of Dawson. Well, it's one of them. It's Ayaz Virji. By his own admission, the man had experienced nothing but respect and positive feelings from the people in Dawson. But Virji had obviously read in the media and heard from other people that Trump supporters are Muslim-haters who would force him onto a Muslim registry and otherwise subject him to all kinds of discrimination. In spite of his personal experiences with them, which were positive in every way, he jumped to the conclusion that they all hated him. And when they told him they didn't and that they liked having him in town, he refused to believe them. The Post wants you to see Ayaz as a sympathetic figure, but it's hard to see why anyone would. If he believes a vote for Trump is the same thing as people hating him, when every experience he's had with his neighbors should tell him otherwise, then he is clearly the kind of person who makes broad and unsupportable assumptions about other people based on their politics. By contrast, it appears the people of Dawson made no judgments or assumptions about Ayaz because he is a Muslim, but instead were warm and welcoming to him as a new member of their community. The fact that they preferred Donald Trump to Hillary Clinton as president of the United States had absolutely nothing to do with their personal feelings toward him or any other person - except Hillary Clinton, whom many of them probably regarded correctly as a corrupt, inept liar who should not be trusted with such power. So yeah, someone in this story is judging others on the basis of scant information. But it's not who the Washington Post wants you to think it is.

Subscribe

View Comments

Dan Calabrese——

Dan Calabrese’s column is distributed by HermanCain.com, which can be found at HermanCain

Follow all of Dan’s work, including his series of Christian spiritual warfare novels, by liking his page on Facebook.


Sponsored