Over thirty different forms of identification can be used as proof--only a few of which require a photo ID or proof of citizenship
At the core of the problem is the centralization of voter records, largely in the form of electronic voter rolls. Congress passed the National Voter Registration Act in 1993 that effectively required states to create central voter registration databases in each state. In addition to information on who is eligible to vote, these also contain information on who has voted in each election.
In every state, these records are poorly maintained, in part because the law requires poor maintenance. By law, voter registrations must be accepted with only minimal evidence that the registration is from a citizen of legal age and otherwise entitled to vote. Over thirty different forms of identification can be used as proof--only a few of which require a photo ID or proof of citizenship. Even a copy of a utility bill or a bank statement can suffice.
Once entered in the rolls, they can only be legally removed by proof of death, a felony conviction, a voter's request for removal, or proof of a permanent move. If those cannot be provided, the registration remains, and remains active.
Multiple investigators across the country, myself included, have found our voter rolls to be filled with duplicate registrations, registrations that are identical except for a day or two difference in birth date, millions of likely non-citizens, active registrations for people who moved away years earlier, voters registered at invalid addresses such as businesses and vacant lots, and yes, a few real legal voters. Does anyone really wonder how elections today can turn up a few million extra voters to change the outcome of an election?
The subsequent additions of motor-voter laws, online registration systems, registration by mail, registration drives by NGOs and other organizations that turn in stacks of completed registrations with no assurance that the forms were completed by legal citizens has made a mockery of any attempt to ensure that our voter rolls are honest.