Fagan’s shortcomings included failing to properly address border security threats, lagging recruitment and retention figures, and mismanaged funding that prevented the acquisition of necessary equipment such as icebreakers and helicopters.
These priorities were slighted because of Fagan’s excessive focus on diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, plus an atmosphere of an “erosion of trust” that was created when Fagan mishandled and covered up aspects of “Operation Failed Anchor” the Coast Guard’s internal investigation into sexual assault cases which took place at the Coast Guard Academy.
Specifically on border security, Fagan is accused of failing to adequately deploy Coast Guard assets to intercept incoming fentanyl and other substances. She also failed to prioritize coordination with DHS on operations along coastal borders.
Fagan’s obsession with DEI policies, including at the Coast Guard Academy, ultimately diverted resources and focus from operational essentials. The DHS official stated that Fagan suffered significant failures in recruiting personnel, exacerbating issues related to operational readiness. Additionally, the official noted that the absence of innovative strategies to tackle retention challenges in critical specialties undermined workforce sustainability.
Under her failed leadership, there were ongoing delays and budget overruns in obtaining essential assets, such as icebreakers and helicopters. An official stated that these issues weakened the Coast Guard's capabilities in the Arctic and other strategic areas. The official also pointed out the lack of accountability for acquisition failures, were emphasized during President Trump's first administration.