Far Better Than DrudgeUnfiltered News • Daily Headlines

CCF intervenes in Crown’s attempt to expand reach of hate speech laws

“If we allow the courts to lower the bar for criminal speech offences, the consequences will extend far beyond this case."


TORONTO – The Canadian Constitution Foundation (CCF) is before the Ontario Court of Appeal today as an intervener in a case examining whether the Criminal Code offence of public incitement of hatred applies to online speech. The CCF will argue that section 319(1) was intended to address incitement in public spaces that risk an imminent breach of the peace in physical spaces, and should not be expanded to cover online expression. Online conduct is already covered by other provisions of the Code, including 319(2), the wilful promotion of hatred.

The case, R v Bory, involves Leslie Bory, who was convicted in January 2025 of advocating genocide, wilful promotion of hatred, and uttering threats for his anti-Semitic speech online.

Bory was acquitted of public incitement of hatred under section 319(1) of the Criminal Code: “Every one who, by communicating statements in any public place, incites hatred against any identifiable group where such incitement is likely to lead to a breach of the peace is guilty of … an offence…” He was, however, convicted of the wilful promotion of hatred, section 319(2).

The Crown is appealing that acquittal, arguing that “any public place” applies to online speech.

The CCF strongly condemns Bory’s statements and does not represent him or defend his views. Rather, the intervention is about ensuring criminal laws are applied as written.

Section 319(1) was designed to address situations such as hate rallies in public spaces, where there is an imminent risk of violence, not online speech. Unlike section 319(2), section 319(1) comes with important defences including a truth defence.

Christine Van Geyn, Interim Executive Director of the CCF, said the case is about ensuring the government does not stretch criminal laws beyond what Parliament intended.

“What the Court decides here will shape how section 319(1) is applied in future cases,” said Van Geyn. “We condemn hatred and I am disgusted by the things Mr. Bory has said online. Society has determined that the type of things Mr. Bory posted online is worthy of criminal sanction under section 319(2) of the Criminal Code, and Mr. Bory was convicted."


"Expanding the scope of 319(1) beyond what Parliament intended violates principles of the rule of law. We do not think a provision meant to address outbursts of violence in public spaces should be extended to speech posted online from one’s office chair. How broadly this offence is interpreted matters to every Canadian who expresses themselves online.”

Josh Dehaas, Interim Litigation Director of the CCF, said the case is about more than the viewpoints of one individual.

“You can find Mr. Bory’s statements reprehensible and still recognize that the Charter of Rights and Freedoms requires us to tolerate speech we do not agree with,” said Dehaas. “If we allow the courts to lower the bar for criminal speech offences, the consequences will extend far beyond this case,” he added.

The CCF will be represented in this intervention by John Mather, Lauren Baker, and Katy Tritt of DMG Advocates. The case will be heard in courtroom 10 starting at 9:30 a.m. EST.

For further information, contact:
Christine Van Geyn
Executive Director (Interim)
Canadian Constitution Foundation
1-888-695-9105 x. 103
cvangeyn@theccf.ca

Josh Dehaas
Litigation Director (Interim)
Canadian Constitution Foundation
1-888-695-9105 x. 104
jdehaas@theccf.ca


Read next: When Hate-Speech Laws are Weaponized

Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments

Canadian Constitution Foundation——

The Canadian Constitution Foundation (CCF) is a registered charity, independent and non-partisan. We defend the constitutional rights and freedoms of Canadians in the courts of law and public opinion.