Example 1- Roger Pielke, Jr., Professor University of Colorado
“Why is it that the expert climate community has been unable or unwilling to correct rampant misinformation about extreme weather with some even promoting that misinformation?”, asks Roger Pielke, Jr. One answer he says, is that the “end justifies the means, or. in other words, doing the right thing for the wrong reasons is OK,” even if that means downplaying or even misrepresenting one’s own research. (1)
He participated in a roundtable discussion hosted at the headquarters of the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) with a group of US Senators, the Secretary of the Treasury and about one-half dozen other researchers.
When the roundtable was announced, Pielke experienced something new in his professional career. Several of his much more senior colleagues contacted him to downplay or even to misrepresent his research on the roles of climate and society in the economic impacts of extreme weather. Pielke had become fairly well known in the atmospheric sciences research community for his work showing that increasing US hurricane damage could be explained entirely by more people and more wealth.
One colleague explained to Pielke that his research, even though scientifically accurate might distract from efforts to advocate for emissions reductions. The colleague said, “I think we have a professional, or moral, obligation to be very careful what we say when the stakes are so high.”
This is where the end justifies the means comment mentioned earlier in this article comes from. Pielke asks the question, “Why is it that the expert climate community has been unable or unwilling to correct rampant misinformation about extreme weather with some even promoting misinformation?” The most important explanation is that many in the climate community appear to believe that achieving emissions reductions is so very important that its attainment trumps scientific integrity. (1)