The contradiction is so glaring that it can only be explained by a desire to exploit that insecurity for electoral gain
Furthermore, their definition of a "right" is inconsistent. Voting, in practice, functions far more like a privilege. It has built-in qualifications: you must be 18, a resident, and not a felon. An inalienable right, like free speech, has no such prerequisites. If voting were a pure right with no obstacles, the logical conclusion would be that "anyone should be able to vote," a position almost no one entertains.
The most damning evidence of their hypocrisy, however, is their own behavior. These are the same people who require ID to enter their town halls, proof of party membership to attend their functions, and ID to vote in their labor union meetings. During the COVID pandemic, they demanded proof of vaccine or a mask to participate in society, often with no exceptions for those with legitimate medical issues.
They understand perfectly well that it is reasonable, necessary, and wise to require proof of identity and eligibility to protect the integrity of an institution--whether it's a political party, a union, or a hospital. They just don’t want to apply that same common-sense security to the country’s ballot box.
When you put these observations together, you are left with a stark conclusion. The arguments against the Save America Act are not based on a consistent principle of rights, a genuine concern for the disenfranchised, or a sincere belief in a frictionless society. They are a calculated political position.
The only remaining explanation is that these opponents of election integrity have concluded that a less secure system, one in which it is easier for ineligible votes to be cast, is in their political best interest. They fight to secure their own private institutions with ID, but they fight to keep the public ballot box as insecure as possible. The contradiction is so glaring that it can only be explained by a desire to exploit that insecurity for electoral gain.