And understand, if you penalize the billionaire for making his money, he will be less likely to engage in the market, take the risks, make the investments, and in turn all that he created for society suffers. Going after the billionaires, in turn, actually hurts the everyday man, and in the long run reduces how much revenue is available for roads and schools--not that fixing the schools is a money problem.
As for the “Billionaires don’t make their money off of their labor” statement, Abdul used the classic communist class warfare approach--creating a class distinction between the “worthy” laborer and the “unworthy” capitalist. This ignores the role of intellectual labor, risk, and organizational labor. The billionaire began the process. They took the chances. They risked their capital and early blood, sweat and tears on a vision that could have failed spectacularly and left them with nothing. They made high-stake decisions to navigate the pitfalls of creating a new venture, of which only a few percentage survives those initial stages. They allocated capital, hired the people, put in place strategies, and innovated. A single bad decision can bankrupt a company, and they took that chance. They organized the labor, creating a cohesive, productive enterprise--an ability and skillset that is truly rare--and thanks to their work to get where they are, many people earn their livelihood. The billionaire’s “fruit of his labors” is value created by their risk, decisions, and organizational skill.
In a collective system where taking those types of chances is penalized, who innovates? Who takes those chances? Who would be willing to risk an investment?
Abdul’s position is that if you take from the rich, and give to the public, everyone wins. And the idea is based on the assumption that all rich people are greedy people who are taking from everyone else, and that government somehow will better manage society through central planning.