Fiddling while Rome burns: Saskatchewan’s pre-occupation with distracted driving
Despite high crime rates, the government, media, and law enforcement agencies focus on trivial motor vehicle infractions
Saskatchewan has a massive crime problem, and it's been this way for many years. And yet, you wouldn't realize it from looking at government policies, apparent law enforcement priorities, and stories in the mainstream media.
Following the release of the most recent crime statistics, the editors of the Regina Leader-Post wrote an editorial entitled "Crime statistics don't tell whole story" on July 26, 2012. In this article, the Leader-Post editors claim the following:
"It's the kind of violent crime spree that would make any citizen nervous: Two people shot dead and 23 wounded in a gunfight at a community barbecue ... two killed and five wounded at a crowded shopping mall ... a man shot dead and another injured at a busy cafe in mid-afternoon. Just an average summer in Canada's worst city for crime? No, the above incidents all happened in Toronto, which was third-lowest on Statistics Canada's 2011 crime severity index (CSI) of 33 Canadian cities. Meanwhile, Regina -- which has led the notorious index every year since 1998 -- feels like a peaceful backwater in comparison. There have been no major violent incidents in public places and just three homicides so far this year."
The intellectual follies of pointing out a single crime event in a major city as some type of useful data should be self-evident. It is pure junk science.
Statistics Canada tracks crime rates in 34 major cities (CANSIM Tables 252-0051 and 252-0052). Here are the relative rankings of Regina (YQR) and Toronto (YTZ) for a range of crime statistics in 2011 (the most recent year for which data is available). Note that a ranking of 1st is the worst (highest crime rate), whereas 34th is the best (lowest crime rate):
- Total, all crimes (excluding traffic): YQR, 1st; YTZ, 34th
- Total violent crimes: YQR, 7th; YTZ, 25th
- Homicide: YQR, 5th; YTZ, 14th
- First degree murder: YQR, 21st; YTZ, 14th
- Second degree murder: YQR, 4th; YTZ, 16th
- Manslaughter: YQR, 3rd; YTZ, 14th
- Attempted murder: YQR, 9th; YTZ, 8th
- Sexual assault, level 3, aggravated: YQR, 1st; YTZ, 14th
- Sexual assault, level 2, weapon or bodily harm: YQR, 1st; YTZ, 12th
- Sexual assault, level 1: YQR, 16th; YTZ, 29th
- Sexual violations against children: YQR, 17th; YTZ, 33rd
- Assault, level 3, aggravated: YQR, 3rd; YTZ, 24th
- Assault, level 2, weapon or bodily harm: YQR, 1st; YTZ, 24th
- Assault, level 1: YQR, 7th; YTZ, 28th
- Total robbery: YQR, 3rd; YTZ, 7th
- Total property crime violations: YQR, 1st; YTZ, 34th
- Total breaking and entering: YQR, 3rd; YTZ, 34th
- Total theft of motor vehicle: YQR, 3rd; YTZ, 20th
- Total theft over $5,000 (non-motor vehicle): YQR, 7th; YTZ, 16th
- Total theft under $5,000 (non-motor vehicle): YQR, 2nd; YTZ, 29th
- Fraud: YQR, 7th; YTZ, 21st
- Arson: YQR, 16th; YTZ, 34th
- Total weapons violations: YQR, 5th; YTZ, 19th
- Child pornography: YQR, 15th; YTZ, 28th
- Total prostitution: YQR, 2nd; YTZ, 28th
- Total cocaine, trafficking, production or distribution: YQR, 1st; YTZ, 20th
- Crime severity index: YQR, 1st; YTZ, 32nd
- Violent crime severity index: YQR, 4th; YTZ, 11th
- Non-violent crime severity index: YQR, 1st; YTZ, 34th
- Crime severity index: CAN, 77.6; SK, 144.8; YQR, 124.5; YXE, 118.7
- Violent crime severity index: CAN, 85.2; SK, 141.4; YQR, 123.5; YXE, 134.5
- Non-violent crime severity index: CAN, 74.7; SK, 146.0; YQR, 124.9; YXE, 112.7
- Youth crime severity index: CAN, 82.6; SK, 220.9
- Youth violent crime severity index: CAN, 88.6; SK, 152.7
- Youth non-violent crime severity index: CAN, 78.1; SK, 272.8
- Total crimes (non-traffic): CAN, 5756; SK, 12272; YQR, 9706; YXE, 9464
- Total violent crimes: CAN, 1231; SK, 2366; YQR, 1497; YXE, 1655
- homicide: CAN, 1.73; SK, 3.59; YQR, 3.15; YXE, 2.16
- Attempted murder: CAN, 1.90; SK, 2.65; YQR, 2.25; YXE, 2.88
- Total robbery: CAN, 86.3; SK, 102.6; YQR, 149.0; YXE, 169.4
- Total property crime violations: CAN, 3520; SK, 6785; YQR, 5672; YXE, 5453
- Total breaking and entering: CAN, 526; SK, 858; YQR, 763; YXE, 669
- Total theft of motor vehicle: CAN, 239; SK, 470; YQR, 489; YXE, 579
- Fraud: CAN, 226; SK, 337; YQR, 308; YXE, 350
- Arson: CAN, 30.1; SK, 59.5; YQR, 29.7; YXE, 38.2
- homicide: 2nd worst
- Attempted murder: 2nd worst
- Sexual assault, level 3, aggravated: worst
- Total sexual violations against children: worst
- Assault, level 3, aggravated: worst
- Total robbery: 2nd worst
- Total property crime violations: worst
- Total breaking and entering: worst
- Total theft of motor vehicle: worst
- Fraud: worst
- Arson: 2nd worst
- Counterfeiting: 3rd worse
- Total prostitution: worst
- Total cannabis, trafficking, production or distribution: worst
- Total cocaine, trafficking, production or distribution: worst
- Crime severity index: worst
- Violent crime severity index: 2nd worst
- Non-violent crime severity index: worst
- Youth crime severity index: worst
- Youth violent crime severity index: 2nd worst
- Youth non-violent crime severity index: worst
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Sierra Rayne——Bio and Archives
Sierra Rayne holds a Ph.D. in Chemistry and writes regularly on environment, energy, and national security topics. He can be found on Twitter at @srayne_ca
