Prime Minister Trudeau testified before the Parliamentary Finance Committee on July 30th in connection with the WE Charity scandal, currently under investigation by Ethics Commissioner Mario Dion.
Canadians can be forgiven for wondering why.
Amping up the Trudeau charm, well lit and smiling directly into a high-resolution camera, coiffed hair blacker than beard; the relaxed PM was clearly focused upon communicating directly with voters, rather than answering questions from committee members. How Many Times? That Is The Question
Finance Committee Hearing or Liberal Campaign Ad?
Prime Minister Trudeau testified before the Parliamentary Finance Committee on July 30th in connection with the WE Charity scandal, currently under investigation by Ethics Commissioner Mario Dion.
Canadians can be forgiven for wondering why.
Amping up the Trudeau charm, well lit and smiling directly into a high-resolution camera, coiffed hair blacker than beard; the relaxed PM was clearly focused upon communicating directly with voters, rather than answering questions from committee members. Trudeau's repetitive and vexatious use of the word "uh"
Also telling was Trudeau's repetitive and vexatious use of the word "uh". In linguistics, "uh" is known as a "hesitation form", or "filler word". Filler words are often a red flag for deception. In Psychology Today, Professor Jack Schafer of Western Illinois University, a behavioral analyst for the FBI, explains. "Little words, often ignored in normal speech, can signal deception. Words such as um and uh indicate cognitive load. Liars experience increased cognitive load. Um and uh signal impending delays is speech. Liars need time to evaluate their answers to ensure their lie will be believed. Liars also need additional time to choose the right words to camouflage the truth. Truthful people do not need extra time to convey information." The Prime Minister wouldn't lie though, would he? So, what are the issues with WE-Gate exactly? The growing Hydra-like list may keep Commissioner Dion up at night:- Was CSSG designed specifically for WE to administer?
- Why the Canada Service Corps was not tasked with CSSG?
- Why a sole-source contract?
- Details of due diligence done, due to the fact that WE appeared to be in financial trouble and in violation of bank covenants. WE Board Members had resigned and mass layoffs of staff had occurred. WE had also never delivered a similar program previously.
- Why was WE paid $30M upfront, and how will it repay taxpayers?
- Why was a WE real estate shell company used, instead of WE Charity?
- Why was a $30M upfront payment made on contract award?
- WE claimed initially that the PMO had called, asking if they wanted the CSSG contract.
- Who authorized WE, and why, to begin spending money on May 5th, prior to June 23rd approval?
- Failure to recuse/Conflict of Interest -
- PM has spoken for WE in past
- WE has paid for Trudeau campaign ads/gave Trudeau a platform to connect with hundreds of thousands of young voters
- WE has paid Margaret and Alexander Trudeau
- WE has paid Sophie Trudeau
- WE relationship with Katie Telford
- WE paid Bill Morneau $42K expenses
- WE employs two Morneau daughters.
Beyond the blatant corruption
Beyond the blatant corruption issues however, the CSSG model may have also been fatally flawed from birth. The very real possibility exists that CSSG could violate Minimum Wage laws. CSSG would pay a student up to $10 per hour, which is less than the minimum wages in all of Canada's provinces and territories. If the concept of paid volunteers seems counter-intuitive, the law actually recognizes two classes of volunteers. According to Labour Law firm Goldblatt Partners, "Volunteers are not covered by the Employment Standards Act in Ontario, and need not be paid the minimum wage. But that does not mean that an employer can evade its obligations under the Act by classifying anyone as a volunteer. Only a ‘true volunteer' is excluded from the protections of the Act…if a participating student views the program as a means to make a livelihood during a time that fewer summer jobs are available, they may be able to argue that they are not a ‘true volunteer.'" A class action lawsuit waiting to happen then. But, back to the show. Poilievre (translation) – "I have a simple question for you. How many times does a Minister in your Government need to break the Ethics Act before being sacked? How many times?" Trudeau (translation) – "We…uh…take it very seriously, every time there are Ethics issues… Poilievre – "How many times?" Trudeau – "…and…" Poilievre – "How many times?" Chair – "The Prime Minister has the floor…and he has the right to answer. Mister Prime Minister" He had the right to answer, but apparently not the ability. How many times? That is the question…for all Canadians. Great campaign slogan for Conservatives next election cycle…Read next: Voting ‘no’ on question ten in the Alberta referendum means saying ‘no’ to the other nine, too
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Ken Grafton is a writer living by the river in Aylmer, Quebec, just downwind from Parliament Hill; with global executive-level experience in engineering and telecommunications. His work has been published in The Hill Times, National Newswatch, National Observer, Canadian Dimension, The Hamilton Spectator, The Welland Tribune, The Peterborough Examiner, The St. Catherines Standard, The Niagara Falls Review, The Waterloo Region Record, The Burlington Post, The Ontario Times, The Muskoka Times, Cambridge Times, The New Hamburg Independent, Hamilton News, Progressive Bloggers, Global News and The Low Down to Hull and Back.
