Check 1: Organic traffic
A site that earns no search traffic can't send you visitors, and Google has little reason to trust what it links to. Start with estimated monthly organic visits.
Under 500 visits a month is an automatic reject. Between 500 and 2,000 is workable but modest, so treat it as a caveat rather than a green light. Also look at the trend, not just the number: a site at 20,000 visits that lost half of it over six months is a warning, not an asset.
When you have more than a handful of domains to check, a bulk screen saves hours. Zevahit's free vetting tool takes a pasted list of domains and returns an accept or reject verdict with the reasons for each one.
Check 2: Link ratio
Divide the site's total backlinks by its referring domains. A healthy publisher earns links from many different sites. A network earns a lot of links from very few.
A ratio around 3:1 is unremarkable. At 10:1 it's worth investigating where the links come from. At 20:1 or higher you're usually looking at the footprint of a link scheme. One exception: very large publishers run high ratios naturally, so don't reject a major news site on this check alone.
Check 3: Authority and spam score
Authority is a 0–100 score derived from the site's backlink profile. Below 20 usually means the site hasn't earned enough trust to pass meaningful value.
Spam score looks at the quality of those backlinks. As a rule of thumb, treat 61 and above as a reject and 31–60 as a note to verify the link sources. Spam scores from any provider are estimates, so a medium score is a reason to look closer, not necessarily to walk away.
Check 4: Topical fit
A site can pass every numeric check and still be the wrong place for your link. Look at the keywords it actually ranks for. If a large share sits in gambling, adult content, celebrity net-worth and biography filler, CBD and vape, essay writing services or movie piracy, the site has drifted away from any real niche, and links from it won't read as relevant.
General-interest blogs that publish on everything are a related problem. A link is worth more when the surrounding site is clearly about something your page is also about.