Why? If he thought the president was trying to derail the investigation, that would seem relevant to the scope of the investigation. It is like a bank president seeking to close a fraud investigation, but the contact in the FBI decided not to tell bank investigators. One explanation would be that Comey did not view Trump as a potential target of the Flynn investigation, and thus did not view the uncomfortable meeting as relevant to the investigation team (and Trump has maintained that Comey told him three times that he was not a target). However, that would make the case even weaker for allegations that Trump was trying to protect himself or his inner circle by seeking closure for Flynn.
It is highly concerning that Trump has described how Comey actively campaigned to keep his job during this period. As usual, Trump has created the most problematic record for judging his own actions. If Comey was pleading for his job as suggested by Trump, the impropriety of the alleged statement in the Oval Office would be exponentially increased. Trump categorically denies that the statement was ever made. That alone could support an immediate demand for any and all tapes in the possession of Trump and he would be required to turn them over.
Don't forget, of course, that Turley is looking at this strictly in the context of the criminal code. If the House decided to impeach Trump, it would not need to prove a violation of the criminal code to get a conviction. It simply has to decide how it will define "high crimes and misdemeanors" in its articles of impeachment, and then it would take 67 senators to decide Trump should be convicted as charged.
I have no doubt that, all things being equal, most congressional Republicans would prefer President Pence to President Trump - and not necessarily for
admirable reasons as we discussed earlier today. But all things are not equal. Mike Pence did not run for president and win the Republican nomination. Donald Trump did. Mike Pence was not on the top of the ticket that won 306 electoral votes. Donald Trump was, with the full support of Mike Pence.
When a president has truly committed a high crime, then Congress has a responsibility to remove him. The situation here is more like this: At worst, Trump asked a very ill-advised question in a private meeting with the FBI director, who then documented it in case he would ever need to go back and make use of the information. For a Congress looking for a pretext to remove a duly elected president, it might just barely do the job. But is it required? Would it be wise?
Those are a few questions I have. Here are some others:
Others have asked this one, but I will too: If Trump asked Comey to do something inappropriate, why didn't Comey resign in protest?
If the investigation of Flynn in particular, and Russia in general, is so important then what evidence has the FBI come up with that anyone did anything wrong?
Did Trump pull an I'm-your-boss-and-you'd-better-give-me-what-I-want routine here? Or did he simply ask for Comey's consideration of the matter? You can argue that it makes no difference in a political context, but if you want to understand what actually happened it makes a world of difference. If Trump acknowledged throughout that it's Comey's call but wanted to nonetheless make the request on Flynn's behalf, that's nowhere near the same thing as pulling rank to kill an investigation.
Did Trump ask because he was worried Flynn would go down? Or did he ask because he thought the whole thing was a ridiculous waste of time that was based on nothing, and he didn't think Flynn deserved that type of harassment? Again, you can say it makes no difference politically, but if you want to understand what happened it's crucially important.
Obama's Justice Department was blatantly sabotaging the FBI's Hillary investigation
Since Trump has already denied asking Comey to shut down the Flynn investigation, and only the two of them were in the room, how can anyone determine with certainty which one is telling the truth? Just because Comey wrote a memo and dated it doesn't mean he can prove its contents are accurate. Let's say Comey was worried from the beginning about his job security from the moment Trump took office, and realized that he could make any claim he wanted about a personal one-on-one meeting with the president, and if it wasn't accurate, the only person who'd be in a position to refute it would be the widely reviled Donald Trump. Would Comey do something like that? I don't know. He came up with a pretty weak pretext for letting Hillary Clinton off the hook, so who knows? And that brings us to this question:
Are we supposed to believe Barack Obama never communicated his desire for Hillary to not be charged? Perhaps Obama plays the game more cleverly than Trump, and he wouldn't call Comey personally into his office and make the request. He would do it with a wink and a nod such that Loretta Lynch would know exactly what was expected, and could make sure Comey knew. So Obama was more sneaky about doing it, while Trump was ill-advisedly straightforward in simply asking. Why do we now reward sneaky and impeach straightforward?
When Obama's Justice Department was
blatantly sabotaging the FBI's Hillary investigation, did Comey write any memos to file about that? Could we see them if he did? And if he didn't, why not?
Who was the anonymous source who leaked this to the New York Times, actually reading the memo to them over the phone? Was it Comey himself? If not, who else did he allow to see the memo?
Last night's media pants-wetting made it sound like, if this memo is for real, Trump's presidency is over. A day later, given time to think it through for those actually interested in doing so, that seems far less clear. But this much is clear: The Beltway establishment is out for this man's head, and they will jump on the first thing they think they've got to try to take him down. I'd be surprised if Trump is impeached over this. But I'd be even more surprised if the next rationale for impeaching him isn't right around the corner.