As he has so often done, Rutenberg bases his entire argument on a faulty premise, which is that Trump attacks journalists who engage in "coverage he does not like." If you watched the entire press conference, you'll see that's not at all what was going on. Trump takes question after question from reporters who have been tough, to say the least, in their coverage of him. The only reporters he won't take questions from are those from CNN and BuzzFeed, and it has nothing to do with "coverage he doesn't like." It's about publishing a bogus bunch of lies about the Russians having salacious compromising information about him.
Trump draws the line clearly and unmistakably for anyone who cares to recognize it: You can be critical in your coverage of him, but you can't just make s*** up, nor can you report information that is unverified and widely believed to be untrue. That's what CNN and BuzzFeed did, and that's why they got smacked.
What's more, Trump offered the exact right antidote for those wondering what he would like to see done about all this: Hire reporters with a moral compass who are interested in telling the truth.
Black Lives Matter leader hit with restraining order after threatening LA police official
Rutenberg does acknowledge in his piece that BuzzFeed handed Trump the stick with his reckless decision to publish the garbage dossier, although I think he let CNN too much off the hook for its own news judgment. Regardless, Rutenberg flits around the edges of the solution but can't quite bring himself to embrace it:
You can argue that the dossier was going to get out there anyway. But it hadn’t until BuzzFeed published it, even though many news organizations, including this one, had it for months. And had the documents leaked by some other means, it would be up to journalists to establish their veracity; ignore them if possible, debunk them if necessary.
That’s what BuzzFeed has done with its top-notch reporting on the “fake news” phenomenon, helping to shine an early light on the false stories so many Americans were sharing on Facebook and other social media platforms throughout the campaign.
But every journalistic misstep gives more fodder to people who want to stop the efforts against “fake news” by turning the tables and labeling those efforts — or any other solid journalism they don’t like — as “fake news” as well, corrupting the term for their own purposes (a classic case of “no, you are!”).
That’s what Mr. Trump did Wednesday morning.
So Rutenberg is troubled that BuzzFeed published fake news, not so much because the falsehood troubles him but because it gives Trump "fodder" to assail the media for doing exactly what the media does. The obvious solution for Rutenberg and his contemporaries in the media is to return to real standards of truth and accuracy in reporting. Publishing a bogus dossier just because "it's out there" is journalistic malpratice in the extreme. Airing an inaccurate story claiming Trump has been shown the dossier (he hadn't) and thus it's newsworthy is almsot as bad.
For far too many years, the media has believed it could do its job as badly as it liked and it should suffer no consequences at the hands of the elected officials it covers because they're the press and that makes them so important. Trump's view seems to largely hue to mine: Because the job of the press is so important, it's a very serious matter when they screw up and they need to be made to pay a price for that. Reporters got to ask Trump lots of questions yesterday, and CNN and BuzzFeed were free to report on what was said in any manner they wished.
But when you've been as reckless and irresponsible as both were, you absolutely should get called out, and you have no inherent right to get called on to ask a question.
If Rutenberg things the media needs a "new strategy" to battle against this reality, then he's part of the problem too. What they need is to tell the truth. Trump has no history of going to war against reporters who criticize him but do so truthfully. If Rutenberg doesn't know the difference, the problem here is bigger than anyone realized.
Dan's new novel, BACKSTOP, is a story of spiritual warfare and baseball. Download it from Amazon here