The balance of beneficiaries “losing coverage” would not enroll in insurance, CBO says, “because the penalty for not having insurance would be eliminated.” In other words, without the threat of government to buy insurance or else pay a penalty, some people will conclude that ObamaCare coverage isn’t worth the price even with subsidies. CBO adds that “a few million” people would use the new tax credits to buy insurance that the CBO doesn’t consider adequate.
The problem with this educated guess about enrollment is that CBO’s models put too much confidence in the effectiveness of central planning. The nearby table shows CBO’s projections about ObamaCare enrollment, which were consistently too high and discredited by reality year after year. CBO is also generally wrong in the opposite direction about market-based reforms, such as the 2003 Medicare drug benefit whose costs the CBO badly overestimated.
Unlike CBO, most economic forecasters publish their assumptions and a range of possible outcomes for different variables. This transparency reveals the uncertainty built into any predictive model, rather than homing in on one number like 23 million, as if it is omniscient. The complication for CBO is that the more it defines its uncertainty, the less authority the political class will invest in its estimates.
To summarize, the CBO completely ignores the fact that any number of variables could affect things play out, and simply assumes that federal central planning always produces the result intended by the central planners. Thus, when there is a retreat in central planning, the result must be that this very same goal can no longer be achieved.