Montgomery County now must pay $1.5 million directly to the families
A federal judge appointed by Biden sided with the board in 2023, determining that the parents had not demonstrated that the storybooks crossed into indoctrination. The 4th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that decision with a 2-1 ruling in 2024.
The parents went straight to the Supreme Court.
On June 27, 2025, Justice Samuel Alito authored a 6-3 opinion that concluded the debate.
"The right of parents 'to direct the religious upbringing of their' children would be an empty promise if it did not follow those children into the public school classroom.”
Six conservative justices signed on: Alito, Thomas, Gorsuch, Barrett, Kavanaugh, and Chief Justice Roberts.
Sotomayor, Kagan, and Jackson were the dissenting justices--these three believe that government bureaucrats should determine what your children learn.
Judge Boardman – the same Biden appointee who originally ruled against the parents – signed the settlement that ended the case.
Montgomery County now must pay $1.5 million directly to the families.
It’s a beautiful thing. The families not only won damages and had their legal fees picked up, which Becket's lead attorney, Eric Baxter, declined to say how much that number is, but the district must now operate under a permanent injunction with ongoing court supervision.
According to the court's ruling, Montgomery County is required to inform all parents, not just those involved in the lawsuit, ahead of time whenever any content related to gender and sexuality is taught at any grade level. Parents also have the right to opt their children out of this instruction.
Baxter proclaimed that, "Public schools nationwide are on notice: running roughshod over parental rights and religious freedom isn't just illegal – it's costly.”