Palestine - Pontification, Prediction and Poppycock
Prime Minister - Benjamin Netanyahu - is to announce a new peace plan in May
The world has been agog this week at the news that Israel's Prime Minister - Benjamin Netanyahu - is to announce a new peace plan in May - possibly in an address to the United States Congress - in an effort to end the conflict between Jews and Arabs in former Palestine.
This conflict still remains unresolved more than 90 years after the signing of Treaty of Sevres in 1920 and the unanimous decision of the League of Nations in 1922 - mandating
Great Britain to reconstitute the Jewish National Home in Palestine in recognition of the historical association of the Jewish people with Palestine - without prejudice to the civil and religious rights of "existing non- Jewish communities in Palestine or the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country".
These decisions relating to Palestine - (which included what is today called Israel, Gaza, the West Bank and Jordan) - had been made in the context of recognizing Arab self determination in 99.999% of the lands of the Ottoman Empire captured by Great Britain and France in World War 1 - whilst the remaining 0.001% of those lands was to be set aside for Jewish self determination.
Speculation has been rife as to what Netanyahu's May proposal will encompass.
One can state with reasonable confidence that any new Netanyahu initiative will receive short shrift from both the Palestinian Authority and Hamas and be totally unacceptable to them.
Ninety years of Arab rejectionism following the promulgation of the Mandate is not suddenly going to evaporate in May - unless Netanyahu's proposal:
- Accepts the right of return into Israel for those Arabs who became refugees in 1948 - and their descendants - who now supposedly number at least 7 million.
- Agrees to hand over control of towns like Ariel, Maale Adumim and Har Homa to the Palestinian Authority and to evacuate the 70000 Jews who currently live there along with at least another 70000 Jews who live in a number of other towns and villages in the West Bank
- Forgoes his demand that Israel be recognized as the Jewish National Home
- Abandons the requirement for Israel to maintain a military presence along the Jordan River
- Acknowledges that any Palestinian State can have its own armed forces and unfettered control of its air space and maritime coastline
"Is he [Netanyahu] running scared? I don't think so.. But there is pressure. And it certainly makes it necessary for a lot of heart-searching and perhaps reappraisals."Any heart searching and reappraisals will be a total waste of time and effort unless all the above concessions are offered. That is not going to happen. Netanyahu is not yet ready to commit national suicide. Israeli Defence Minister - Ehud Barak - wants to see Netanyahu release his proposals before May - telling Israel Radio:
"Such a decision must be taken in the coming weeks, not the coming months. A declaration before the Congress in May would be far too late,"One could equally postulate that a decision in May would be far too early - indeed that no such decision should be made until
- Hamas and the Palestinian Authority bury their political differences
- A single unitary governing body exists in the West Bank and Gaza that is capable of making,honouring and enforcing any agreements that might be signed with Israel
- The political situation has been stabilized in Egypt and Jordan and the continued operation of the peace treaties signed by Israel with these countries is assured.
- The newly elected governing body in the West Bank and Gaza resumes direct negotiations with Israel
"The world will not accept that we continue to rule over another people after 43 years,"Barak is talking poppycock. Under the Oslo Accords - negotiated in 1993:
- 96% of the West Bank Arab population is ruled over by the Palestinian Authority - not Israel - so far as their civil rights and administrative control are concerned .
- 55% of the West Bank Arab population is ruled over by the Palestinian Authority - not Israel - so far as their security protection is concerned.
Read next: Why "Free Palestine!" and Not Also "Free Kurdistan!"?
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
David Singer——Bio and Archives
David Singer is an Australian Lawyer, a Foundation Member of the International Analyst Network and Convenor of Jordan is Palestine International—an organization calling for sovereignty of the West Bank and Gaza to be allocated between Israel and Jordan as the two successor States to the Mandate for Palestine. Previous articles written by him can be found at: jordanispalestine.blogspot.com
