
Palestinians’ Machinations at the United Nations Continue
Imposing deadlines for resolving the Palestinian-Israeli conflict on Palestinian terms, including full Israeli withdrawal from all “occupied” territories within three years

The Palestinians thought they had the necessary nine-vote majority to pass the resolution, which would have forced the United States to use its veto power to defeat it. As it turned out, the Palestinians missed their target by one vote.
The Security Council rejected the Palestinian bid to end-run direct negotiations with Israel by a vote of 8 members in favor of passage, 2 against and 5 abstentions.
The 8 countries voting in favor of the resolution were the Permanent Members France, China, and Russia, and the non-permanent members Jordan, Argentina, Chad, Chile, and Luxembourg. The United States and Australia voted against the resolution. The 5 abstaining countries were Nigeria, the United Kingdom, Lithuania, South Korea and Rwanda.
France’s UN Ambassador Francois Delatorre explained France’s shameful yes vote as motivated by “the urgent need to act, by the profound necessity to change our methods, by the responsibility incumbent upon each member of the Security Council” France acceded to the Palestinians’ formula for a two-state solution, to be established through UN’s mechanisms and timetables rather than good faith direct negotiations between the parties to the conflict.
The French ambassador declared that only the Security Council can provide the “indisputable foundation in order for the negotiations to be credible. It is up to us to determine internationally recognized parameters to resolve the conflict, and negotiations that lead to the satisfaction of the various claims.” To that end, France went along with the deadline imposed by the draft resolution for completion of all negotiations and the withdrawal of Israeli forces from the “occupied” territories. It gave up on its own more temperate compromise draft.
The defeated draft Palestinian resolution included the following language, which attempted to set the parameters for final resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict on the Palestinians’ terms:
- “Affirms the urgent need to attain, no later than 12 months after the adoption of this resolution, a just, lasting and comprehensive peaceful solution that brings an end to the Israeli occupation since 1967 and fulfils the vision of two independent, democratic and prosperous states, Israel and a sovereign, contiguous and viable State of Palestine, living side by side in peace and security within mutually and internationally recognized borders;
- Decides that the negotiated solution will be based on the following parameters:
- borders based on 4 June 1967 lines with mutually agreed, limited, equivalent land swaps;
- security arrangements, including through a third-party presence, that guarantee and respect the sovereignty of a State of Palestine, including through a full and phased withdrawal of the Israeli occupying forces, which will end the occupation that began in 1967 over an agreed transition period in a reasonable timeframe, not to exceed the end of 2017, and that ensure the security of both Israel and Palestine through effective border security and by preventing the resurgence of terrorism and effectively addressing security threats, including emerging and vital threats in the region;
- a just and agreed solution to the Palestine refugee question on the basis of Arab Peace Initiative, international law and relevant United Nations resolutions, including resolution 194 (III);
- a just resolution of the status of Jerusalem as the capital of the two States which fulfils the legitimate aspirations of both parties and protects freedom of worship;
- the just settlement of all other outstanding issues, including water and prisoners;”
- Internationally recognized borders between an independent state of Palestine and Israel based essentially on the June 4, 1967 lines
- Security Council affirmation of the Palestinians’ assertion of their refugees’ so-called right of return to their so-called homes within pre-June 1967 Israeli borders; and
- International recognition of the Palestinians’ claim to East Jerusalem (including the Old City with its holy sites) as their capital.
Read next: Communist Cuban Regime Shows its True Colors at the United Nations
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Joseph A. Klein, CFP United Nations Columnist——Bio and Archives
Joseph A. Klein is the author of Global Deception: The UN’s Stealth Assault on America’s Freedom.
