How the Story Got Buried
As the centuries passed, folk customs gathered around the days. Poor people went door to door at Hallowmas, receiving food in return for prayers for the dead (New World Encyclopedia, 2026). A secular version, guising, is first recorded in Scotland in the 19th century (Soniak, 2024). Historians also link the holiday’s unique customs to the festival of Samhain (Rogers, 2002). That festival, at the turn from autumn to winter, was the time when the Celts believed the boundaries between the worlds of the living and the dead blurred (Britannica, 2026). Costumes and masks were also worn during the festivals in order to placate the evil spirits (New World Encyclopedia, 2026).
America came late to all of this. The Puritans of New England strongly opposed the holiday, and it arrived in earnest only with Irish and Scottish immigration in the 19th century (New World Encyclopedia, 2026). The earliest known printed use of “trick or treat” is from a 1927 Alberta newspaper (Mark, 2025). After a wartime pause, the practice surged in the 1950s (Soniak, 2024). By then the connection to the saints had faded, and the scary side of the holiday has since become a commercial industry of its own.
Most Protestants lost the habit of remembering along the way. But we weren’t meant to.
Room at the Protestant Table
Some of us may hesitate to remember the saints of old because we aren’t Roman Catholic, and we don’t pray to the saints. Neither did the Reformers. Martin Luther posted his 95 Theses on the eve of All Saints’ Day, at a church where those attending the celebration of the saints would see them (Warstler, 2006). The Lutheran reformers kept the day and cherished it. The Augsburg Confession says Scripture does not teach calling on the saints for help, yet the memory of saints should be honored, so that believers can imitate their faith and good works (Melanchthon, 1530/2000b, Art. XXI). The Apology of the Augsburg Confession strongly encourages the remembrance of the saints for three purposes: thanksgiving to God, strengthening of faith, and imitation (Melanchthon, 1531/2000a, Art. XXI).
That is the pattern I want to recover. We do not pray to the saints. We thank God for them, and we learn from them. Hebrews 11 gives us the roll call. Some “were tortured, refusing to accept release.” Others endured “mocking and flogging, and even chains and imprisonment.” They were “of whom the world was not worthy” (Heb. 11:35–38). Then comes the verse that turns the memorial into a mission: “Therefore, since we are surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses, let us also lay aside every weight… and let us run with endurance the race that is set before us” (Heb. 12:1).
We already understand this instinct. Every year we pause to honor those who gave their lives for our country. We sing of heroes “who more than self their country loved, and mercy more than life” (Bates, 1913). If we can do that for a nation, surely we can pause for those who gave everything for “a faith of equal standing with ours” (2 Pet. 1:1). Their Lord promised, “Be faithful unto death, and I will give you the crown of life” (Rev. 2:10).