It is a violation of their First Amendment rights to force them to say something that isn’t true, just to accommodate another person's mental illness
Take, for instance, a vote taking place today at the Elk Grove Unified School District in California. In October of 2024, Board Policy 5145.18 was approved unanimously by the board. That regulation stipulated that students in grades 4 through 12 can face suspension or expulsion if staff are involved; they can be disciplined and/or fired.
So, what crime could these students and teachers be disciplined for? The regulation addresses the district's nondiscrimination policy, and although it isn't specifically mentioned, it could cover cases where someone doesn’t use a student’s chosen name or pronouns as gender-based harassment.
Keep in mind, these are kids who can be as young as nine, ten, eleven, and twelve years old. Kids raised by responsible Christian parents who have correctly taught their children that there are only two genders. Male and female, men and women, boys and girls. It is a violation of their First Amendment rights to force them to say something that isn’t true, just to accommodate another person's mental illness.
It also violates the Free Exercise Clause of that Amendment, which protects citizens' rights to practice their religion—or no religion at all—freely without government interference to conform.
Heidi Moore, who represents Area 7, joined the board after the 2024 vote. She correctly expressed her concerns to the California Family Council about Administrative Regulation 5145.18, echoing rational thinkers' concerns that it restricts students' First Amendment free-speech rights and religious protections.
Moore has previously been the only dissenting vote on other transgender-related issues, including initiatives concerning girls' sports and proclamations for Pride Month.
The California Family Council reports:
“Under the heading “Issues Unique to Transgender and Gender-Nonconforming Students,” the regulation lists conduct that “may constitute gender-based harassment.” The first example reads: “Refusing to address a student by a name and the pronouns consistent with the student’s gender identity.”