In 1946, David Ben Gurion submitted to the “Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry” a document - “
No Arab Majority in the Land of Israel ” by Israel A. Trivus – highlighting the fundamental demographic flaws - some of which still persist today - of both censuses. For example, the censuses were supervised and conducted by British and Arab individuals known for their hostility toward the idea of a Jewish state and involvement in anti-Jewish terrorism; most forms were filled and submitted by Hamula leaders, whose interest was to maximize their political clout and benefits and therefore their numbers; most Arab adults were illiterate, unable to comprehend/complete the forms; the registration of the Arab inhabitants was never scrutinized; the registration of nomad Arabs (Bedouins) was heavily inflated; the population registration suggests that death was rarely reported; migrants from rural to urban areas were doubly-counted in both locations; overseas residents were included in the censuses.
According to official British Mandate statistics, the Arab natural increase in the Land of Israel was, ostensibly, the highest in human history, dramatically higher than the natural increase in the Arab world…. A June 10, 1993 study on the Arab population of Judea and Samaria, by Israel’s Central Bureau of Statistics, echoed the unreliability of Palestinian population registration, stating: “If the Palestinian population registration is accurate, then Palestinian life expectancy is higher than life expectancy in the USA….”
In the 1940s, on the eve of the Declaration of Independence, Israel’s Founding Father, David Ben Gurion, was pressured by Israel’s leading statistician and demographer, the founder of Israel’s Central Bureau of Statistics, and the role model of Israel’s current statistical/demographic establishment, Prof. Roberto Bacchi, to postpone the establishment of the Jewish state for lack of a critical Jewish demographic mass. According to Bacchi’s October, 1944 projection, the number of Jews in the Land of Israel, in 2001, was supposed to be 2.3 million, a 34% minority – this was a cataclysmic error.
Like Israel’s contemporary demographic establishment, Prof. Bacchi erred in dismissing the prospects of Aliyah waves (continuous since 1882), attributing to Arab fertility permanent mythical rates, assuming that Jewish fertility would be reduced to European levels, ignoring the eventual Westernization of Muslim demography in general and Palestinian demography in particular, while Jewish demography (3.11 births per woman, and 3.4 when both spouses are Israeli-born) trends above Muslim demography, everywhere other than the Sudan, Yemen and Iraq.
In 2015, in defiance of the “Demographic Scaremongering Fraternity,” Israel’s Jewish demography features an astounding 68% surge in the number of annual births from 1995 (80,400) to 2014 (132,000), while the annual number of Arab births has stabilized (40,000) due to accelerated modernity; a growing positive Jewish net-migration, simultaneously with growing Arab negative net-migration; a 66% Jewish majority in the combined area of Judea, Samaria and pre-1967 Israel, benefiting from an unprecedented tailwind of fertility and migration. Should Israel resurrect the pro-active Aliyah policy, which was Israel’s flagship until 1993, Jewish demography – and therefore economy, technology, national security and posture of deterrence - would catapult to new heights.
Theodor Herzl’s motto, “if you will it, it is no dream,” has been vindicated resoundingly.
Wishing you
Shabbat Shalom, rewarding weekend and Happy Chanukah