How, then, can any free and democratic society have a Chief Justice spluttering such figments of his lurid imagination?
Contradicting the assertion that the protest was the beginning of what the Chief Justice called “anarchy and an exercise in hostage-taking,” Ontario’s Superior Court Justice Andrew Goodman said, when releasing her on bail, “Ms. (Tamara) Lich is not charged with sedition or inciting a riot.” And nothing happened remotely resembling what the Chief Justice called “forced blows against the state, justice and democratic institutions …” How, then, can any free and democratic society have a Chief Justice spluttering such figments of his lurid imagination? Or was he simply besotted with deference to the overblown inventions of the Prime Minister and members of his cabinet?
Responding to a complaint to the CJC about what the Chief Justice said, acting executive director Jacqueline Corado wrote this: “Considering that your complaint is unsupported, is largely based on a hypothetical scenario, is manifestly without substance, and does not concern judicial conduct, it does not warrant further consideration by the Council.” Did the Chief Justice himself write that?
In a similar case in 1982, the CJC conducted an inquiry into comments made by then Justice Thomas Berger of the BC Supreme Court. With comments appearing in an article he wrote for the Ottawa Citizen and elsewhere, the judge was concerned about the entrenchment of native rights and language rights in the constitution. He said the apparent decision of the first ministers to “abandon” native rights to be “mean-spirited and unbelievable.” In his own defence, Justice Berger wrote, “The issues which I discussed transcended partisan politics.” This is what the CJC said about Justice Berger’s conduct: