There is the specter that unauthorized distribution could occur, at the behest of the AI client, in exchange for funds. If a paying AI client receives (able to download) complete works of copyrighted content for personal or business use, re-distribution or inclusion in research papers or other works, royalties should be rendered to the author/publisher for each full download. As is any research paper, thesis or dissertation, excerpted content quoted must be credited to the author by proper reference.
This is what could change despite what Anthropic or any other frontier lab claims is the current purpose of reproducing by digitizing copyrighted material:
“What matters [ ] is not so much ‘the amount and substantiality of the portion used’ in making a copy, but rather the amount and substantiality of what is thereby made accessible to a public [in the purported secondary use] for which it may serve as a competing substitute [for the primary use].”
The point that copies could be used for other purposes that infringe on the copyright is valid: “This factor points against fair use when a copyist makes copies available that displace demand for copies the copyright owner already makes available or readily could.”
This is Anthropic’s contention – “The copies used to train specific LLMs did not and will not displace demand for copies of Authors’ works, or not in the way that counts under the Copyright Act.” But since LLMs constantly lie, euphemistically called hallucinating, this cannot be trusted and may need to be addressed by appending copyright laws on the books.
The author-plaintiffs in the lawsuit also worried that others could utilize their works as examples for creating competition. From the case: “Authors contend generically that training LLMs will result in an explosion of works competing with their works.”
That shouldn’t be much of a concern. Fair competition in the world of writing presses authors to produce high quality works they can sell to support their skill and art. Good writers are voracious readers, always learning from the excellence of those who’ve gone ahead. William Faulkner said: “Read, read, read. Read everything… Just like a carpenter who works as an apprentice and studies the master. Read! You'll absorb it…”