In 2015, SpaceX’s Falcon 9 suffered a catastrophic failure, destroying $118 million worth of cargo headed for the International Space Station in the process. Following the incident, NASA conducted an investigation to determine the cause and potential ramifications from the crash. Per the organization’s standard practice, NASA was set to publicly release the report upon completion. But rather than potentially embarrass SpaceX by finding it at fault, NASA decided against a public disclosure of the investigation’s results and allowed Musk’s personal investigation, which blamed a supplier, to rule the day. This was a seemingly unprecedented move from NASA, which had publicly released reports of mishaps from SpaceX’s competitors in similar circumstances. Apparently, in NASA’s eyes, SpaceX warranted an exception.
For more recent proof, look no further than NASA’s response to SpaceX’s Crew Dragon debacle. In 2014, NASA initially contracted SpaceX to build and launch reusable shuttles to transport both crew and supplies to the International Space Station. Five years later—and two past its deadline—SpaceX still hasn’t delivered. What’s more, the shuttle’s current iteration is woefully unreliable. This year alone, the Crew Dragon has experienced two monumental setbacks. In March, the craft’s parachute system failed, causing it to crash in the ocean upon reentry. Then, in April, the shuttle experienced a critical failure during launch, resulting in the entire capsule erupting into flames.
Surely, NASA has realized the error of its ways, and is scaling back SpaceX’s involvement in the program going forward, right? With any other contractor, perhaps that would be the case, but with SpaceX, think again. Instead, Musk received a scornful tweet from Jim Bridenstine, the Administrator of NASA, highlighting the delays that the Crew Dragon program has endured. Then, only a few days later, the two made amends, with NASA announcing that once again, it was “very confident” in SpaceX.
Clearly, NASA is allowing Elon Musk and SpaceX to play by a different set of rules. And while NASA may be content to fund Musk’s bad behavior and poor performance, the American taxpayer shouldn’t be. Whether SpaceX’s rockets are failing to meet deadlines or their CEO is breaking federal law by smoking weed, NASA is allowing the company to waste millions of taxpayer dollars. Americans must demand better than SpaceX is providing us. And if the company can’t perform, its due time NASA find a contractor that can.