Is US President Donald Trump the new Franklin Delano Roosevelt? Does his immigration policy mimic Roosevelt's by adopting a callous, bigoted position on would-be asylum seekers from the Muslim world?
At a press conference on June 5, 1940, Roosevelt gave an unspeakably cynical justification for his administration's refusal to permit the desperate Jews of Nazi Germany to enter the US.
In Roosevelt's words, "Among the refugees [from Germany], there are some spies... And not all of them are voluntary spies--it is rather a horrible story but in some of the other countries that refugees out of Germany have gone to, especially Jewish refugees, they found a number of definitely proven spies."
The lessons of Roosevelt's failures
Trump's executive order is far from perfect. But in making the distinction between the hunters and the hunted and siding with the latter against the former, Trump is showing that he is not a bigot
Is US President Donald Trump the new Franklin Delano Roosevelt? Does his immigration policy mimic Roosevelt's by adopting a callous, bigoted position on would-be asylum seekers from the Muslim world?
At a press conference on June 5, 1940, Roosevelt gave an unspeakably cynical justification for his administration's refusal to permit the desperate Jews of Nazi Germany to enter the US.
In Roosevelt's words, "Among the refugees [from Germany], there are some spies... And not all of them are voluntary spies--it is rather a horrible story but in some of the other countries that refugees out of Germany have gone to, especially Jewish refugees, they found a number of definitely proven spies."
The "Jews" in the present circumstances are not the Muslims, who are nowhere targeted for genocide. The "Jews" in the present circumstances are the Christians and Yazidis and other religious minorities, whom Trump's impassioned Jewish opponents and Obama's impassioned Jewish champions fail to defend. Trump's executive order is far from perfect. But in making the distinction between the hunters and the hunted and siding with the latter against the former, Trump is showing that he is not a bigot. Unlike his critics, he has learned the lessons of Roosevelt's moral failure and is working to ensure that the US acts differently today. Originally published in the Jerusalem Post.
Read next: War Powers Lessons from the Revolutionary War
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Chicago-born Caroline Glick, Center for Security Policy], is deputy managing editor of the Jerusalem Post. A former officer in the Israel Defense Forces, she was a core member of Israel’s negotiating team with the Palestinians and later served as an assistant policy advisor to the prime minister. During Operation Iraqi Freedom, the widely-published Glick was an embedded journalist with the U.S. Army’s Third Infantry Division. She was awarded a distinguished civilian service award from the U.S. Secretary of the Army for her battlefield reporting.
