Two recent stories explain the source of this cognitive blockage.
The first story involves Lt. (res.) Dean Issacharoff.
Issacharoff completed his IDF service in 2015 and went to work for Breaking the Silence where he serves as the anti-IDF group’s spokesman.
Breaking the Silence is a foreign government-funded organization that works to blacken the IDF’s reputation by publishing generally anonymous war crimes allegations against Israeli soldiers.
At a Breaking the Silence conference in Kiryat Ono on April 4, Issacharoff was filmed telling his audience that he himself is a war criminal.
Issacharoff said that during his military service as a combat officer in Hebron, he violently assaulted a Palestinian who posed no threat to himself or his soldiers.
Issacharoff said that he committed this crime in front of his soldiers and his company commander.
On April 25, Ad Kan, a volunteer organization that counters radical political NGOs, sent a letter to Attorney-General Avichai Mandelblit asking him to open a criminal probe against Issacharoff. Ad Kan attached a video of Issacharoff’s remarks to its letter.
Given the severity of the crimes Issacharoff claims to have committed, Mandelblit could have been expected to immediately order the State Prosecution’s Criminal Division to launch a probe. But as it happened, for two weeks, Mandelblit sat on his hands.
Then, on May 7, Issacharoff’s claims came to the public’s attention when another volunteer organization, Reservists on Duty, which defends IDF soldiers from slander, exposed it in an online film. Issacharoff’s company commander and his soldiers stood before the camera and one after another they rejected his claims saying, “Dean Issacharoff, you’re a liar.”
Two days later Mandelblit forwarded Ad Kan’s letter to his criminal division.
The reason that Ad Kan and Reservists on Duty were compelled to act is that the IDF’s legal authorities have been amazingly passive about Issacharoff’s claims. The Military Advocate-General’s Office rejected Reservists on Duty’s request to open a criminal probe into Issacharoff’s claims.
The MAG claimed that since Issacharoff’s alleged crimes were committed more than a year ago, the State Prosecution rather than the IDF is responsible for investigating and prosecuting him.
But in truth, if the IDF wanted jurisdiction over its reserve officer who is publicly slandering its soldiers and officers, all it needed to do was call him to duty and send him to the Military Police for investigation.
The fact that the IDF has refused to take action, and that Mandelblit only transferred Ad Kan’s letter to his criminal division after the story hit the news, indicates that Israel’s military and legal establishment would have let Issacharoff get away with either committing a war crime or slandering his fellow soldiers and officers if Ad Kan and Reservists on Duty hadn’t alerted the public.
This then brings us to the second story. It revolves around Breaking the Silence’s comrades in B’Tselem.
Over the past decade, B’Tselem has spent millions of shekels on a campaign to slander the IDF and its soldiers.
The foreign-government financed group’s Camera Project uses video production to blacken the IDF’s good name and impede its operations. Participants in B’Tselem’s Camera Project enter closed military zones in Judea and Samaria with video cameras. The selectively edited videos they produce uniformly portray IDF soldiers and officers as cruel and callous.
Over the years, B’Tselem’s snuff film project has damaged the IDF’s international reputation, its operational capacity and the morale of its soldiers. But despite the fact that it has numerous legal means to fight B’Tselem, the General Staff has taken no action against the group.
This week, emboldened by the IDF’s passivity, B’Tselem escalated its campaign against the IDF.
On Sunday B’Tselem posted a menacing message on its Facebook page addressed to the parents of a young active duty IDF officer.
It read, “To the parents of the officer with a beauty mark over his upper lip, that in February of this year served by the Yitzhar settlement: If you want to bask in the glory of your son the hero in the course of his operational activities, go to the Cinematheque in Tel Aviv. Your son will be starring in a film there – cocking his weapon against civilians… barking orders in broken Arabic…”
A photo of the officer and two of his soldiers was posted below the message.
B’Tselem’s action was prominently covered in the media. Its video of the officer and his soldiers was played and replayed.
This was no mere snuff film.
B’Tselem’s post, publicly shaming a serving officer, was a steep escalation of its political war against the IDF and its soldiers and officers. Now all IDF soldiers and officers are on notice. The next B’Tselem post may be a defamatory post against them addressed to their parents.
Given the demoralizing effect B’Tselem’s assault on the officer and his family had on their soldiers, the generals might have been expected to open criminal proceedings against B’Tselem.
But that didn’t happen.
Instead, the IDF Spokesman, Maj.-Gen. Moti Almoz, wrote a post on his Facebook page.
“Greetings to all of our slanderers,” he began.
Rather than pledge to take necessary legal action to defend IDF soldiers and officers from abuse and harassment at the hands of B’Tselem, Almoz treated B’Tselem’s hostile act as an adolescent prank.
Almoz concluded his post, which never even mentioned B’Tselem by name, “You will continue to make movies as if in the name of freedom of expression, despite the fact that your expression is unconnected to reality. And we will continue to protect the people of the State of Israel and ensure the security of its citizens, without inserting the IDF into political disputes.”
Almoz’s conclusion is particularly problematic because the fact is that his statement that the IDF’s position is apolitical is misleading.
It is true that there is nothing political about soldiers lawfully carrying out their missions. But, the General Staff’s decision not to defend its soldiers and officers from the likes of B’Tselem and Breaking the Silence is a political decision.
In choosing to treat anti-Israel groups like Breaking the Silence and B’Tselem with kid gloves, the General Staff is inserting itself directly into Israeli politics.
Likewise, when IDF generals lobby Congress to maintain US funding of the PA, and when “military sources” express their opposition to Trump’s plan to move the US Embassy to Jerusalem, they are behaving as political activists.
This returns us to Netanyahu and his frustration at Trump’s sudden embrace of the PLO, which places the most pro-Israel president in history on a collision course with Israel.
Netanyahu is right to be angry. But his rage at Lauder is misdirected. The real culprit is the General Staff.
Since no prime minister can dispute the holy grail of “security concerns,” Lauder, the vain billionaire got blamed.
This situation is insufferable. Our generals cannot continue to receive a pass for their political activism.
When they lobby for the PLO and against moving the US Embassy to Jerusalem they cross the line into gross insubordination. When they protect Breaking the Silence and B’Tselem rather than their soldiers, they commit a grave dereliction of duty.
Originally published in The Jerusalem Post.