Trump is hardly the first statesman to question the importance of NATO or to try and extend an olive branch to Russia and other adversaries. A few years ago, left-wing publications like the
Nation and the
Guardian published articles that portrayed NATO in highly unflattering terms. The
Nation claimed NATO was no longer necessary and that its post-Cold War expansion “alienated Russia and deepened divisions in Ukraine and the Caucasus.” The
Guardian quoted Robert Gates, former defense secretary for both George W. Bush and Barack Obama, as he predicted a “dismal” future for the alliance.
The Center for American Progress, founded by Hillary Clinton’s 2016 campaign chairman, John Podesta, took the opposite tack, issuing a
report urging NATO to become more accommodating to Russia and to facilitate military-to-military cooperation between the alliance and the Russian Federation. In 2012 when NATO held a summit in Chicago, an estimated 2,000 to 3,000 protesters took to the
streets. These groups all appeared to be very left-wing: anti-war, anarchists, and the Occupy Wall Street movement were among the most visible. The Rev. Jesse Jackson was there with women holding signs that said “Afghans for peace.” By the end of the protest, around 45 protesters were arrested and two were detained on charges of
terrorism.
Trump’s speech makes it clear he is not merely a captive of conservative activists. The president is willing to look at America’s commitments throughout the world and ask whether they actually provide value. Trump said he wants allies in “NATO, in the Middle East, or the Pacific … to take a direct and meaningful role in both strategic and military operations.” This aspect of the emerging Trump Doctrine puts world leaders on notice that the U.S. can no longer afford to write blank checks. The Trump administration will support other nations as long as they share a common interest with the U.S. and are willing to contribute to their own defense.
In his speech the president gently slapped the United Nations by saying “[w]e will respect historic institutions, but we will also respect the sovereign rights of nations.” Trump has
questioned the current state of relations between the UN and the U.S. and has considered halting funding for the global body. He has urged the United Nations to respect the sovereign rights of nations, which could lead to conflict between the UN and Israel.