The Washington Post Discovers the Problems with Energy Subsidies
Institute for Energy Research, end to all energy subsidies
Any time Congress considers subsidizing politically-favored sources of energy, it should consider the following questions:
- What if the subsidies do not make a politically-favored energy source cost-effective?
- What if the politically-favored energy source turns out to be less than advocates envision?
- Can Congress kill a subsidy program after it has created a constituency that is receiving taxpayer dollars?
- Won’t Members of Congress fight to keep subsidies to help their districts?
Uncertainties abound: What if the costs of clean coal don’t come down enough to make it economical relative to other measures? If clean coal turns out to be less than its advocates envision, can Congress ever work up the political will to kill the subsidy program? Subsidies are set to phase out after 10 years of paying for operating costs, but won’t powerful coal-state lawmakers fight to keep them going? And even if it does work, won’t members of Congress insist that big carbon repositories not be located in their districts?But the Post seems to suffer from economic amnesia, as it has argued many times in the past that economic intervention in its pet sources of energy is a necessity. For example, during the debate of the 2007 House energy bill, the Post lamented the lack of a “renewable energy standard”—a mandate forcing Americans to use more renewables. The Post explained:
Also making the House energy package less than optimal is the lack of a renewable energy standard. If the United States is going to ease its dependence on fossil fuels, it must institute a national benchmark for utilities to use more wind, solar, biomass or geothermal energy.And while there is reason to be concerned about subsidized carbon dioxide capture technology at coal-fired power plants, the verdict has already been issued with respect to renewable energy. For over 30 years the Federal and State government have been subsidizing renewable energy because of the claims made by proponents of renewables that breakthroughs are just around the corner. Consider the two headlines from the Wall Street Journal. Thirty years ago the Carter Administration believed that solar power would provide 20% of our energy needs in 2000. In 2008, solar produced less than 0.1 percent of our energy, even though it was heavily subsidized in the interim.
Read next: Energy Policy in a Post-Trudeau Canada Paper
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Institute for Energy Research——Bio and Archives
The Institute for Energy Research (IER) is a not-for-profit organization that conducts intensive research and analysis on the functions, operations, and government regulation of global energy markets. IER maintains that freely-functioning energy markets provide the most efficient and effective solutions to today’s global energy and environmental challenges and, as such, are critical to the well-being of individuals and society.
