Murray’s report would easily meet the definition of hate speech
Murray’s report would easily meet the definition of hate speech. However, none of the victims fall within the protected categories that can make a complaint. So, Murray publishes hate speech with complete impunity. But those who criticize her do not have that protection. If Bill 63 is enacted, she mig t complain that this essay constitutes hate speech.
Murray entitles her second interim report, Sites of Truth, Sites of Conscience: Unmarked Burials and Mass Graves of Missing and Disappeared Indigenous Children in Canada.
She starts with a quote from a UN official:
“The temptation to rewrite history for political purposes is irresistible for governments in some countries…. The writing of history has always been a battlefield, but only archives can ensure that the historical debate can take place on an informed basis.”
Murray does not see the irony in this. She wants to have all archives closed to everyone except people of whom she approves. She wants her view of history to be imposed on Canada, with no independent researchers being able to challenge it with facts from the archives. And she claims everyone who disagrees with her is rewriting history.
She then goes on to claim: (italics are my emphasis)
“The Final Report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada provides indisputable historical evidence of genocide, crimes against humanity, and mass human rights violations in the Indian Residential Schools System.”
She claims that the “supposedly benevolent goal of assimilating Indigenous Peoples…masked a more sinister reality.”
Her “sinister reality” is that the TRC report provided “indisputable evidence of genocide”.
This is of course, entirely untrue. It has not been proven that a single child was ever murdered or ever went missing.