This week we received a few reminders that in certain significant ways, the discourse in Israel and hence the policymaking is very much stuck in the 1990s.
The first reminder came on Sunday when Jordan’s King Abdullah abruptly announced that he is rescinding two annexes of the peace deal that then prime minister Yitzhak Rabin signed with his father the late King Hussein in 1994. Not only did he give Israel no prior warning of his plan to abrogate the annexes, but Abdullah made the announcement on the 23rd anniversary of Rabin’s assassination.What was Rabin’s legacy?
Rabin’s actual vision tells us something important about how the Left’s draconian restrictions on freedom of speech have harmed Israel.
This week we received a few reminders that in certain significant ways, the discourse in Israel and hence the policymaking is very much stuck in the 1990s.
The first reminder came on Sunday when Jordan’s King Abdullah abruptly announced that he is rescinding two annexes of the peace deal that then prime minister Yitzhak Rabin signed with his father the late King Hussein in 1994. Not only did he give Israel no prior warning of his plan to abrogate the annexes, but Abdullah made the announcement on the 23rd anniversary of Rabin’s assassination.Why is Israel’s strategic discourse in relation to the Palestinians stuck in the 1990s?
So what has prevented Israel from walking away from failure? Why has Israel not exercised its option to act unilaterally to secure its strategic and national interests in Judea and Samaria in light of the Palestinians’ self-evident bad faith? Why is Israel’s strategic discourse in relation to the Palestinians stuck in the 1990s? We received a clear answer to that question on Sunday during the official memorial ceremony for Yitzhak Rabin at Mt. Herzl military cemetery. Rabin’s granddaughter Noa Rothman used the official event to launch a diatribe against Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and, oddly enough, against me. Rothman accused Netanyahu of destroying Israeli democracy. Without a shred of evidence – and indeed with the daily news of the criminal probes against Netanyahu; the media’s hatred for him and its support for the EU-funded radical Left; and in the face of the Supreme Court’s growing penchant for overthrowing laws and government policies without any significant legal basis for its actions – Rothman said, “The problem is that in our country these days, doubting is akin to treason, criticism is taken as pettiness, and a demand for setting an example is construed as political persecution.” She then attacked Netanyahu for not following the policy positions of the Left. In her words, “When did one of the nation’s leaders in these times give legitimacy to a dissenting voice, God forbid: not as part of a cynical political debate but honestly, in the name of pluralism – which is so vital to democracy, to our very existence, to our future.” Then she got to the part about me.After Rabin was murdered, Israel’s political Left – including the media – moved to demonize the entire political Right
And this brings us to the real reason why Israel’s discourse and through it, its policies are stuck in the 1990s. After Rabin was murdered, Israel’s political Left – including the media – moved to demonize the entire political Right, accusing it of inciting Rabin’s murder. The clear purpose of the demonization was to make it impossible to criticize the Oslo process, which had already been largely discredited by the suicide bombings which commenced just months after the initial deal was signed at the White House. Following the assassination, every statement of criticism for the peace process was immediately attacked as support for Rabin’s assassin. Netanyahu, who was head of the opposition in the Knesset, was demonized as Yigal Amir’s brain. The notion that Netanyahu’s constructive and fact-based criticism of the peace process was what precipitated Amir’s crime was sheer madness. But all the same, the Left has been accusing him of soliciting Rabin’s murder for 23 years. The empty accusations of incitement against right-wing critics of Oslo, which are nothing more than a means to silence debate, has similarly never ended. And it has worked, as Israel’s continued abidance by the failed accords makes clear. Indeed, the Left’s efforts to silence debate have been so successful that people have forgotten what Rabin’s actual vision for a final peace deal with the PLO was supposed to look like. Leftist activists who continue to revile Netanyahu and all non-leftist voices as inciters and partners in Rabin’s assassination have erased the truth of who Rabin was and what he stood for. Those who accuse voices on the Right of plotting the next assassination by rejecting the Left’s increasingly radical policy positions on everything from economics to religion to national security policy have been working for 23 years to reinvent Rabin as someone that he never was. Rabin made clear what he stood for at his final speech before the Knesset. On October 5, 1995, a month before he was killed, Rabin presented the interim agreement with the PLO – what was later dubbed “Oslo 2” – to the Knesset for approval. The interim agreement followed the Gaza-Jericho agreement which was signed in May 1994 and implemented in July. The Gaza-Jericho deal set up the Palestinian Authority in Gaza and the city of Jericho. The interim accord extended the jurisdiction of the Palestinian Authority to the Palestinian cities and villages in the rest of Judea and Samaria. It kept the rest of Judea and Samaria, what was dubbed on the maps as Area C, under full Israeli civilian and military control.Read next: Pope Leo XIV will not Continue Francis’ Legacy
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Chicago-born Caroline Glick, Center for Security Policy], is deputy managing editor of the Jerusalem Post. A former officer in the Israel Defense Forces, she was a core member of Israel’s negotiating team with the Palestinians and later served as an assistant policy advisor to the prime minister. During Operation Iraqi Freedom, the widely-published Glick was an embedded journalist with the U.S. Army’s Third Infantry Division. She was awarded a distinguished civilian service award from the U.S. Secretary of the Army for her battlefield reporting.
