By Christian Newswire ——Bio and Archives--June 25, 2010
American Politics, News | CFP Comments | Reader Friendly | Subscribe | Email Us
In June 2004, the Supreme Court affirmed a lower federal court decision which had upheld a preliminary injunction blocking enforcement of the Child Online Protection Act, a law that would have required websites that commercially distribute pornography to take reasonable steps to keep kids away from the smut. In so doing, the Supreme Court agreed with the trial court's finding that "blocking or filtering technology may be at least as successful as COPA would be in restricting minors' access to harmful material online without imposing the burden on constitutionally protected speech that COPA imposes on adult users..." Specifically, the trial court found (in the words of the appellate court) that requiring adults to "identify themselves as a precondition to accessing disfavored speech" would "likely...deter many adults from accessing that speech." Five Supreme Court Justices went along with this nonsense despite the fact that COPA contained privacy protection requirements to prevent disclosure of information obtained for the purpose of verifying the age of those viewing or purchasing the smut. This is not to say that online privacy isn't important, regardless of the nature of the speech, but so is the protection of children from exposure to hardcore pornographic content that depicts, among other things, degradation of and violence against women. And despite what some Justices may still want to believe, parental use of filters alone will not protect children from exposure to online pornography, if for no other reason than that today's children have access to the Internet from devices that parents can't control. As for yesterday's Court decision regarding political speech, I would agree that there are valid reasons for requiring disclosure. But those who have followed the gay rights movement for any length of time also know that the threat of hurtful retaliatory conduct is real.
View Comments
Christian Newswire the Nation’s Leading Distributer of Religious Press Releases.