Far Better Than DrudgeUnfiltered News • Daily Headlines

Why Strong Families Do More Than Any Government Programme

Anyone weighing up a new scheme can start by asking whether a household is better able to do its own job a year after the scheme begins;


-- Sara Edwards

Strong families do most of the daily work of raising children, and government programmes tend to succeed when they support that work instead of trying to replace it. A household offers things a department can't schedule or budget for, including a parent who notices a change in mood, a grandparent who collects a child from school and an older sibling who explains how the homework works.

None of this makes public services unimportant. Schools, health visitors and the benefits system carry real weight for families that need them, and many parents would struggle without that backing. The more useful question is where public money does the most good, and for children in particular the answer is often wherever it helps a family stay able to do its own job.


What Families Give Children Every Day

Time: Parents and grandparents give hours that no service has the budget to match, and a lot of what children learn about honesty, effort and kindness comes out in ordinary moments such as the school run or a conversation over tea. A caseworker with a full list of families can't be present for those, however good they are at the job, because their time has to be shared across many families.

Knowing the child: A relative notices that a chatty seven-year-old has gone quiet after a bad week at school and does something about it that same evening. Professionals pick up on the same signs where they can, but they usually see a child for an appointment at a time, while family members see the whole picture every day. Those small details rarely reach a file, yet they often decide whether a problem is noticed early.

Staying power: Funding rounds end, pilots close and staff move on, whereas a parent or grandparent is usually still involved years later. That continuity counts most at points such as a change of school, a house move or a first job, when a young person needs someone who already knows the history and doesn't have to start from a file.

Public Systems Already Lean on Families

At the end of March 2024, 56,390 looked-after children in England were living with foster carers and 16,150 were in residential care, according to the National Audit Office. That's more than three times as many children in a family home as in a residential setting, which says a lot about how much of the care system is built around households.

Carers in those homes may receive a foster care allowance towards the child's food, bills and everyday costs, which can help cover what a child needs while the daily work of parenting stays with the household. The child still gets bedtime routines, help with reading and an adult who turns up to the parents' evening, and none of that appears as a line in a council budget.

The National Audit Office also puts the cost of a residential place at around eight times that of a foster placement, with councils paying an average of £318,400 a year for each children's home place in 2023 to 2024. The saving is only part of the case, since a child placed with a family also lives in an ordinary household with familiar routines and the same adults year after year, which is harder for a home run on staff rotas to offer, however committed the team is.



Where Programmes Work Best

Help is easier to use when it arrives where a family already is, through the school gate, the health visitor's call or a grandparent who's already involved, instead of asking parents to rebuild their week around a new set of appointments. Programmes built that way spend less effort getting people through the door and more on the support itself, and a parenting group held at a school the child already attends can reach parents who might not book a separate course. Parents are also more likely to keep using help that fits around work and school hours than help that needs time off.

In fostering, public money covers the costs one household can't carry alone while the carers decide how a particular child's day runs, an arrangement other programmes could copy. Families plan around the support they're given, so a childcare place, a benefit or a respite service that disappears after a funding round leaves parents back where they started, and the trust built with a local worker is hard to rebuild once it's gone.

Unpaid Care Inside Families

Unpaid carers in England and Wales contribute care valued at £162 billion a year, an estimate from Carers UK and the University of Sheffield that sits close to NHS funding of about £164 billion in 2020/21. Much of that care goes to older, ill or disabled relatives and friends, and it happens in ordinary homes without an appointment, a rota or a handover.

A system that had to replace that work with paid services would need to find the staff, the buildings and the money for all of it. Support that helps carers carry on, including respite breaks, fair allowances and employers willing to be flexible, protects a great deal of care that's already being given for free. A carer who can keep their job, get to their own medical appointments and take the occasional weekend off is more likely to keep caring for years, and that continuity is what the whole arrangement relies on.

Supporting Families Without Taking Over

Governments can't supply a grandparent at the school gate or a parent at the tea table, and even well-funded services can't match the hours that a committed family gives. What they can do is make it easier for families to keep doing that work, by paying for costs that are too large for one household, backing carers with breaks and training, and keeping support in place long enough for families to rely on it. Anyone weighing up a new scheme can start by asking whether a household is better able to do its own job a year after the scheme begins. 

Sara Edwards covers topics of Human Interest and Lifestyles.


Read next: Families step forward to expose what they say is government-funded child kidnapping carried out under the banner of CPS

Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments

News on the Net——

News from around the world