By Robert Laurie —— Bio and Archives August 1, 2018
Comments | Print This | Subscribe | Email Us
The fact that conservatives benefit from the First Amendment is not something to bemoan. It is part of the constitutional bargain. https://t.co/8Mfpgy7QZw
— NYT Opinion (@nytopinion) August 1, 2018
“Have conservatives hijacked the First Amendment? Critics are increasingly making this claim, maintaining that under Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., the First Amendment, once an important safeguard for progressive speech, has become a boon to corporations, conservatives and the powerful. But in most instances, the First Amendment doesn’t favor speech of the right or the left; it simply takes the government out of the business of controlling speakers by virtue of what they say. It often empowers the powerless. And most important, it helps check official abuse. To be sure, conservatives and corporations are invoking the First Amendment, and sometimes winning. In Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, the Roberts court deployed the First Amendment to guarantee that corporations can engage in unlimited campaign spending. A recent study found that the Roberts court has more often protected conservative than liberal speakers.”I literally have trouble believing this was published in a major American newspaper. I understand that the left is furious over recent losses. I get that they despise the fact that the constitution is designed to limit government power. I’m aware that they view it as a nuisance. However, I was raised in a time when the left-wing mantra was: “protect the speech you hate to guarantee the speech you love.” What happened to them? Where did that thinking go?
…these developments should not lead liberals or progressives to lose faith in the First Amendment. For starters, the amendment’s core requirement is that the government must remain neutral regarding the content and viewpoint of speech. As a result, a decision protecting conservative speech will equally support liberal speech.Well… “duh.” I honestly don’t know how else to respond. An NYT editorial has deftly pointed out that the U.S. Constitution applies to every U.S. citizen. Shocker.
The fact that conservatives benefit from the First Amendment is not something to bemoan. It is part of the constitutional bargain. It simply means the First Amendment is operating as it should, neutrally preserving the lifeblood of democracy.Yes, Mr. Cole. We agree. Conservatives have always agreed with this. Maybe you should spend a little more time focusing on the left – because that’s the source of calls to eliminate free speech. We’re glad you’ve finally noticed …and we’re deeply concerned that you had to.
Robert Laurie’s column is distributed by HermanCain.com, which can be found at HermanCain.com
Be sure to “like” Robert Laurie over on Facebook and follow him on Twitter. You’ll be glad you did.