By Warner Todd Huston —— Bio and Archives April 29, 2009
Comments | Print This | Subscribe | Email Us
Among those in regular attendance are David Brooks and Maureen Dowd of the New York Times, Gene Robinson and Ruth Marcus of The Washington Post, NBC’s David Gregory, ABC’s George Stephanopoulos, PBS’s Gwen Ifill, the New Yorker’s Jane Mayer, Vanity Fair’s Todd Purdum, former Time managing editor Walter Isaacson and staffers from Bradley’s Atlantic and National Journal, including Ron Brownstein, Andrew Sullivan and Jonathan Rauch.No Brit Hume, no George Will, not even a Charles Krauthammer? Shocking, eh? Or more like expected. Kurtz tries to liken these secret media programing dinners to those long-held dinners put on by Godfrey Sperling until he retired from the Christian Science Monitor. But those dinners were not secret, were on the record, and were also not by invite only as are the Atlantic’s dinners. Kurtz also mentions the famed 3-hour-long dinner that Obama had with conservative media types during the transition phase of his presidency, but this is also lacking as a direct comparison. That dinner was also not secret, nor is it a recurring meeting. Kurtz also reports that a few Bush folks have been invited to the dinner. Carl Rove is mentioned, but one rather assumes he had long since left the Bush White Hose before that invite came. From Kurtz’ reporting, it seems rather clear that this secret dinner has been rather more left-leaning than not. I suppose that isn’t too surprising, however, seeing as how the dinner regulars are of such ideological similarity. Anyway, what we see from this is more proof of the insular, even incestuous, world the Old Media inhabit. From Emanuel’s secret daily phone calls, to the “journolist” — a secret lefty website message board they all collude on — now to secret dinners, it all seems “rather cozy,” indeed. And all this secrecy also belies the Old Media’s claims that “transparency” is as important as they keep claiming it is. They want the government to be open and transparent, they want Fox News to prove who it funds and supports, yet all the while as the Old Media tsks everyone else for not be transparent, they themselves have had secret phone calls, secret message boards and secret dinners. Not only “cozy” but hypocritical, too.
Warner Todd Huston’s thoughtful commentary, sometimes irreverent often historically based, is featured on many websites such as Breitbart.com, among many, many others. He has also written for several history magazines, has appeared on numerous TV and radio shows.
He is also the owner and operator of Publius’ Forum.