One problem with the Green Deal’s EUDR lies in its indiscriminate, dogmatic application of punitive measures
The starting point should be liberalizing, rather than raising barriers, and working with allied trading partners that have similar principles. And yet, the EUDR is a perfect example of a regulation that has the EU actively working against its closest partners; it’s also been disastrous for the EU’s international image. Indeed, other than a few single-issue NGOs and a handful of unelected EU officials, the Commission would be hard-pressed to find any EUDR proponents.
Second, trade policy needs to be strategic, not dogmatic. China and Russia – especially in their growing alliance with Iran, North Korea and other BRICS countries – are the most obvious and significant threats to the global economic order, and Europe has a responsibility to mitigate such threats.
Weaponizing trade is justified when the goal is preventing carnage in Ukraine, or stopping hacking or surveillance equipment from being installed in grid and other networks. Similarly, deliberate attempts to dump subsidized products or flood markets should not be confused with free trade and should be addressed accordingly. In such cases, a smart, deliberate, targeted response is warranted.
One problem with the Green Deal’s EUDR lies in its indiscriminate, dogmatic application of punitive measures, including against allies like Malaysia, Mexico, Thailand or the United States. Moreover, materials targeted under the EU Deforestation Regulation (rubber, coffee, cocoa, palm oil and cobalt) are key ingredients for Europe’s own supply chains