Can Israel rely on foreign peacekeepers and security guarantees?
Israel is urged to concede the historically and militarily most critical mountain ridges of Judea and Samaria, in return for a US, or a multinational, peacekeeping force, as well as US security guarantees or defense pact.
In order to be effective, defense pacts, and security guarantees – including peacekeeping monitoring or combat forces - must be reliable, durable, specific and politically/militarily sustainable. It must serve the interests of the foreign entity, which dispatches the force, lest it be ignored or summarily withdrawn.
However, the litany of US commitments, guarantees and defense pacts are characterized by four critical attributes – escape routes - designed to shield US interests in a way which undermines the effectiveness of the commitments:
- Non-specificity, vagueness and ambiguity, facilitating non-implementation;
- Non-automaticity, facilitating delay, suspension and non-implementation;
- Non-implementation if it is deemed harmful to US interests;
- Subordination to the US Constitution, including the limits of presidential power.
According to Prof. Noah Pelcovits, Political Sicence, UCLA: "[In the context of security arrangements] there is only one chance in three that the protector will come to the aid of its ally in wartime, and then only at the discretion of the protector.... What counts is the protector's perception of self-interest. Otherwise, the commitment is not honored...."
Prof. Michla Pomerance, International Relations, Hebrew University, stated that US defense commitments, including the NATO Treaty, "are uniformly characterized by vagueness, non-specificity... and the explicit denial of any automatic obligation to use force... [in] accordance with the desire of the US, as promisor, to keep its options open.... Evasion by means of interpretation would not be a difficult task...."
The stationing of foreign peacekeeping tropps on Israel's border would cripple Israel's defense capabilities, requiring Israel to seek prior approval in preempting or countering belligerence, which would also strain US-Israel ties. At the same time, appearing to have enabled Israel to act freely, would damage US-Arab ties.
The assumption that inherently tenuous, intangible, open-ended and reversible US security commitments constitute an effective compensation for critical Israeli land, tangible, irreversible concessions – such as a retreat from the strategically and historically critical mountain ridges of Judea and Samaria – reflects detachment from the Washington constitutional labyrinth and recent precedents, engendering a false sense of security, thus compromising the existence of the Jewish state, transforming Israel from a robust national security producing asset to a frail national security consuming liability, undermining US interests and US-Israel relations.
The next video will expand on the inherent non-reliability of US and international security guarantees.
Read next: Hostages versus IDF soldiers and Israel’s security
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Yoram Ettinger——Bio and Archives
Ambassador (Retired) Yoram Ettinger is an insider on US-Israel relations, Mideast politics and overseas investments in Israel’s high tech. He is a consultant to members of the Israeli Cabinet and Knesset, and regularly briefs US legislators and their staff. A graduate of UCLA and undergraduate at UTEP, he served amongst other things, as Minister for Congressional Affairs at Israel’s Embassy in Washington. He is the editor of “Straight from the Jerusalem Cloakroom and Boardroom” newsletters on issues of national security and overseas investments in Israel’s high-tech.
