Restrictions on property rights come closer to home when they affect our ability to use land as we see fit. Even amidst a tragic housing shortage, Canadian provinces have allowed municipalities to pass zoning and land use restrictions that prevent homeowners and home builders from addressing our pressing housing needs.
Despite being embroiled in political controversy, Ontario’s Greenbelt is a prime example of the extensive and often unwarranted land use restrictions that hinder the availability of land crucial for expanding housing options. Urban containment boundaries, such as the Greenbelt and the Agricultural Land Reserve (ALR) in British Columbia, drive up housing prices by restricting land supply in urban areas globally.
While the IPRI ranking shows Canada performing above average on physical property protections, this masks the fact that Canada is much lower in the rankings than other high-income, highly developed countries, and is declining, not improving.
Canada lacks national constitutional protection for property rights and is well behind many other European and advanced economy countries when it comes to compensating landowners entangled in expropriation and so-called regulatory takings proceedings. Regulatory takings refer to regulations that remove all reasonable land uses from the owner or are, in effect, almost the same as an actual expropriation.