This commission, which was appointed by the Israel-hating UN Human Rights Council and chaired by the longtime Israeli-hating Navi Pillay, did not conduct a truly independent, objective inquiry. Far from it. Her commission’s lies and distorted findings were foreordained before it even started its work. All they do is to feed more fodder to Hamas’s and Iran’s propaganda machines.
UN Watch published a rebuttal to the UN Commission of Inquiry’s report, calling it “fatally deficient” in several respects. For example, UN Watch pointed out that the report “selectively misinterprets statements by Israeli leaders, accepts unverified Hamas casualty figures, disregards Hamas’s systematic use of human shields, relies on unverified media reports (such as by Al-Jazeera), and assumes that civilian deaths in Gaza are only the result of deliberate targeting by Israel.”
The most critical deficiency of all is the Commission of Inquiry’s woeful failure to prove the most fundamental element of the crime of genocide in violation of the 1948 UN Genocide Convention. The Commission fell far short of proving with reasonable certainty that Israel committed any of the acts enumerated in the Convention “with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group as such.” This specific intent is known in international law as dolus specialis. The authors of the Commission of Inquiry’s report think that repeating the legal Latin phrase dolus specialis nine times in their report and relying on sketchy evidence are sufficient to prove their case.
First, Pillay and her fellow Israel haters quoted, out of context, scattered statements made by members of the Israeli government, which they alleged to be “direct evidence of dolus specialis.” The Commission of Inquiry report claimed, for example, that “Statements calling on Israel to exact vengeance against Hamas were made as early as 7 October 2023.” This, of course, was the tragic day that Hamas led its genocidal rampage in Israel, slaughtering, raping, torturing, and abducing innocent Israeli civilians.