Manny Jules, chief commissioner of the First Nations Tax Commission, told a parliamentary committee in 2012 that ATRs had limits within the productive economy.
So, although all evidence suggests Naawi-Oodena will be productive and make great money, there are limits as compared to being owned outright.
Secure and robust fee simple ownership makes buying and selling land much easier and straightforward.
Allowing non-Indigenous partners to have joint interest in land makes for easier third-party investment and partnerships with mainstream investors. Reserve land can’t be used as collateral so raising capital is challenging.
Federal meddling has costs.
Finally, despite appearing outwardly independent, urban reserves continue federal paternalism. If First Nations seek complete freedom, they should aspire to abandon reserves in any shape. Urban reserves – despite benefits – perpetuate the colonial reserve system.
Fortunately, First Nations have a choice as they can outright own new lands.
Canada’s modern treaties moved communities away from the reserve system but with limits.
In 1971, Alaska Indigenous tribes signed an agreement where they extinguished rights in exchange for full control over millions of acres of land and a generous cash settlement. Alaska Natives have no reservations and no Bureau of Indian Affairs control.
A forthcoming Frontier Centre study examines the Alaska experiment in abandoning the reservation system. Canada can learn from Alaska.
Until First Nations abandon reserves, urban reserves certainly help First Nations develop economically. However, urban reserves should open a wider conversation about moving away from reserves.
Joseph Quesnel is a Senior Research fellow with the Frontier Centre for Public Policy.who is Quebec Metis by heritage.