When people exercise their right to free speech, then others must tolerate it
Talk about an existential threat to self-government! And they’re the ones who shriek about how unarmed people marching peacefully to the Capitol to express their views mounted an insurrection to try to overthrow “our democracy?
Basic premise #2. When people exercise their right to free speech, then others must tolerate it. In other words, we may not agree with what others say, and they may not agree with what we say, but neither of us can restrict what the other says.
There are traditions and precedents in law that serve to define and set boundaries for speech. These are matters for the common law and for local and state courts. When someone utters a potential slander or writes a potential libel, action may be taken in the courts to deal with it because it’s a civil wrong. A statement labeled “misinformation” means that someone may be misinformed. A statement labeled “disinformation” means that someone may be deliberately stating false information in order to mislead. If we want a society with free speech, we will have to accept that others may be misinformed, or may want to sow false information. That’s not news. If there’s a possible slander or libel, sue. If it’s something you disagree with, formulate a better argument or just chill.
Since the whole covid era began, efforts to silence some points of view have intensified. These efforts are wrongheaded at a basic level. The next time someone says that another’s speech must be suppressed because they don’t agree with it, it should be easier to identify the real threat to our constitutional republic.
Free speech means that people are allowed to be right or wrong, and none of us gets to define what that is. The US Constitution says it’s protected, and that’s good enough for me.