"Is it government's role to mandate mutual tolerance?
Do we really want the federal courts and the federal government making decisions regarding our rights, like that?
Doesn't the 1st Amendment begin with the words "Congress shall make no law"? And if the legislature can't touch these issues, what makes the courts think they can? The federal court system
does not have the authority. Such an authority
is not expressly enumerated in the United States Constitution. . . at all!
For those of you who wish to use the
Marbury v. Madison argument,
it's a bad argument. Do you really wish to believe the courts can give themselves authorities through the opinions of activist judges?
Attorneys for Phillips have explained that he seeks to exercise his freedom only to speak messages that he agrees with, while still welcoming all customers into his store. The First Amendment’s free speech and religious liberty clauses protect his freedoms to do just that, according to his legal team.
We must ask ourselves, "Is it government's role to mandate mutual tolerance? Is it government's role to compel our speech, and force us to participate in a movement even if we are in disagreement with it? Should, then, atheists be forced to bake Christian cakes? Should Muslims be forced to bake Jewish cakes? Should gay bakers be forced to bake cakes with anti-homosexuality messages on them? If the Christian must be forced to bake a gay wedding cake, then the previous situations must also be allowed. We live in a society where we demand that there is no preferential treatment, right? Besides, how is a disagreement over a sexual behavior even remotely related to 'discrimination'? Do we really want government imposing its view of marriage on the rest of us? Must we be mindless automatons who only agree with government dictates (resistance is futile)? If government must guarantee the rights of gays with Christian Bakers, then it would be reasonable to assume government must also guarantee the rights of Christians around homosexual business owners and force those gay business owners to comply with the demands of Christian customers, even if the homosexual business owner disagrees with it, right?"
The thing is, the whole definition of our "Constitutional Rights" is a large part of the problem, here. We don't have Constitutional Rights. We have "Natural Rights" that were given to us by God, not by government. It is not the government's role to guarantee our rights, and subsidize or force by law our rights, should we not have access to our rights because of other citizens. If it is government's role to guarantee our rights, and use the courts to order that our rights are complied with, then I must ask, "Where's my court-ordered gun?"
Now that the Supreme Court has a hold of the cake case, the truth is, no matter what happens, there are going to be unintended consequences connected to the ruling that will change our society forever - and that is not a good thing. Government has no authority to be involved in our natural rights, or the institution of marriage. Frankly, the Constitution was written in such a way as to tell the federal government, "None of your business, don't touch." The problem is, in many ways we are living in a post-constitutional America. The Rule of Law has become the Rule of Man, and when that happens, it's normally not very long before the people begin dancing around a golden calf.