This is hardly ideal because many of the Calls to Action are fast being enacted into laws with minimum evaluation that will, without a doubt, have grave and expensive consequences for Canadian society including Indigenous people.
Many Canadians believe that being critical of the TRC Report shows that they are disparaging—or worse, racist—towards Indigenous people. But not all critics are racists, and few racists, either non-Indigenous or Indigenous, make good, cogent arguments.
Unfortunately, most Canadians do not realize that the TRC Report has many troubling claims.
Let us examine one of these claims.
DY (Her initials) was a student in the Anglican Residential School at Washakada (Elkhorn), Manitoba. She testified:
I remember was, there was all these screams, and there was blood over the, the walls. [Crying] … and we were told that if we, if we were, if we ever told, or tried to run away, we would, the same thing would happen to us. [Crying] So, it was a dangerous time for, for children, and for me at that, those days. [Crying] We never really knew who would be next to be murdered because we witnessed one already. [Crying]
This statement is certainly horrifying. But is it true?
Unfortunately, no one knows, not even the Commissioners.
Two of the Commissioners, Murray Sinclair and Wilton Littlechild, are lawyers and they listened to DY’s heart-breaking testimony, yet they never questioned her about what she reported. As well, they never questioned other students who were living in the school at the time, and they never even questioned school employees about DY’s claim.