The litigants and courts will also encounter the bitter reality that
the “fundamental transformation” they so earnestly seek means covering
the planet with wind turbines, solar panels, transmission lines … and
the quarries and mines to build them. America already lacks sufficient
EV charging stations and step-up and step-down transformers for new
homes and a functional grid. Millions more will be needed in short order
to reach Net Zero – which means thousands of new mines, quarries,
processing plants and factories.
Toyota Motor Corp. calculates that “more than 300 new
lithium, cobalt, nickel and graphite mines are needed to meet the
expected battery demand by 2035.” That’s essentially just for new EVs,
and getting them approved and developed would likely take decades. A US
energy transformation – to say nothing of a global transformation –
would require thousands of mines, and thousands of processing
facilities.
The process of converting cobalt, lithium, aluminum, iron, rare
earths, manganese, nickel and other ores into high-end metals is
fossil-fuel-intensive, greenhouse-gas-emitting and dirty. “Reaching the
nickel means cutting down swaths of rainforest,” the Wall Street Journal notes. “Refining it … involves extreme heat and high pressure, producing waste slurry that’s hard to dispose of.” Using little children to mine cobalt and processing rare earth elements involve legendary ecological and human rights abuses.
Worse, all this is only the beginning of the planetary desecration.
We’re talking millions of onshore and offshore wind turbines, billions
of solar panels, hundreds of thousands of miles of new transmission
lines, billions of half-ton battery modules – and all that goes into
making them. We’ll have to replace fertilizers for crops and feed stocks
for thousands of products, by planting millions more acres in food and
fuel crops, destroying more wildlife habitats. Turbine blades chop
millions of birds and bats from the sky every year. Offshore turbines disorient whales and dolphins, causing many to beach themselves and die.
Then we’ll have to bury the broken, worn-out and obsolete panels,
turbine blades and other equipment. The world has already installed some
100,000 wind turbines and 2.5 billion solar panels. In whose backyards will the landfills go for all this trash – and the massive lakes for the waste slurries?
There is nothing clean, green, renewable, sustainable or climate-friendly about any of this.
The Supreme Court – and courts, regulators and legislators everywhere – have a lot of work to do.
Paul Driessen is senior policy advisor for the Committee For A Constructive Tomorrow (www.CFACT.org) and author of books and articles on energy, climate change, environmental policy and human rights.
Contact me: pkdriessen@gmail.com