I suggested that the questionable legality of Resolution 2334 needed to be urgently resolved by the Security Council seeking an advisory opinion from the International Court of Justice (“ICJ”) under article 96(a) of the United Nations Charter.
The General Assembly so acted when it sought an advisory opinion in 2003 from the ICJ on the legality of the security barrier erected by Israel.
That decision was fundamentally flawed because contrary to Article 65 (2) of the ICJ Statute--two vital documents--the Mandate for Palestine and article 80--were not included in the dossier of documents submitted to the ICJ for consideration by then UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan--an omission never explained until today.
Indeed the Egyptian Judge sitting on that case--Justice El Araby--cautioned in his judgement:
“The international legal status of the Palestinian Territory (paras. 70-71 of the Advisory Opinion), in my view, merits more comprehensive treatment. A historical survey is relevant to the question posed by the General Assembly, for it serves as the background to understanding the legal status of the Palestinian Territory on the one hand and underlines the special and continuing responsibility of the General Assembly on the other.