NAT GAS Act “Benefits” Only Half of the Equation
When government officials impose legislation at the whim of special interests or just because they would rather see more people driving natural gas vehicles, it creates a chain reaction, the cost of which is not always immediately visible
'a law, gives birth not only to an effect, but to a series of effects. Of these effects, the first only is immediate; it manifests itself simultaneously with its cause--it is seen. The others unfold in succession--they are not seen: it is well for us, if they are foreseen. Between a good and a bad economist this constitutes the whole difference--the one takes account of the visible effect; the other takes account both of the effects which are seen, and also of those which it is necessary to foresee.'[v]In the case of the NAT GAS Act, what we would see is more natural gas vehicles (NGVs) and less money in government coffers, but the story doesn't end there. The reason why we don't see more natural gas vehicles now is that people currently don't value them enough to buy more of them. If they did, producers and consumers wouldn't need government incentives. What will be seen and is not considered is that the NAT GAS will create an increased demand for natural gas and raise the price. Considering natural gas's variety of uses, ordinary people will be hit with these higher prices everywhere they turn. Around fifty percent of US homes use it as their primary fuel for heating. "Natural gas is also used in homes to fuel stoves, water heaters, clothes dryers, and other household appliances."[vi] Natural gas provides about 24% of the United States' electricity.[vii] If the price of natural gas goes up, so does the cost of everything it goes into. As such, this bill can be seen as an indirect tax on consumers of natural gas, considering 39 million Americans cook dinner with natural gas every night[viii]. Like most regulation, it would hurt the people who can least afford it and would affect those low or fixed income consumers the most.
Conclusion:
When government officials impose legislation at the whim of special interests or just because they would rather see more people driving natural gas vehicles, it creates a chain reaction, the cost of which is not always immediately visible. These costs however, are no less relevant and must be foreseen. In this economic climate the last thing we should be doing is making it harder for families to get by and incentivizing others to be less productive. Instead, we should consider treating all energy sectors the same under the tax code and let real competition and value creation take place, as opposed to continuing to pervert incentives and harm consumers. [ia] Bill Summary & Status 112th Congress (2011--2012) H.R.1380, The Library of Congress: Thomas [ii] H.R.1380--New Alternative Transportation to Give Americans Solutions Act of 2011, Opencongress.org [iii] Two Approaches to Fuel Choice, Robert Zubrin [iv] Who was Frederic Bastiat [v] "That which is Seen, and That which is Not Seen" Frederic Bastiat [vi] How Natural Gas Is Used, Economic Information Administration [vii] Electric Power Annual, Economic Information Administration [viii] American Petroleum InstituteRead next: Half of Airline Pilots Who Crashed Planes Were Muslim
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
The Institute for Energy Research (IER) is a not-for-profit organization that conducts intensive research and analysis on the functions, operations, and government regulation of global energy markets. IER maintains that freely-functioning energy markets provide the most efficient and effective solutions to today’s global energy and environmental challenges and, as such, are critical to the well-being of individuals and society.
