Specifically, Schmidt relied on arguments made by Martha Koch, an education professor at the University of Manitoba. In a recent op-ed, Koch went as far as to suggest that teachers who take more university math courses are less effective at teaching math than those who took fewer courses.
Not only does this contradict common sense, but it also flies in the face of real research. Together with eight of her colleagues, University of Winnipeg math professor Anna Stokke took the time to review the studies cited by Koch. They found that the research evidence contradicted Koch’s claims.
For example, several articles cited by Koch asserted that it was important to have better math content preparation for prospective teachers. One article even suggested that all prospective teachers should complete at least six credit hours in math as an admission requirement to an education program—exactly the opposite of what Koch had claimed.
In addition, Stokke and her colleagues found plenty of research studies that reported a positive correlation between math courses taken by teachers and student academic achievement. Unsurprisingly, Koch didn’t cite these studies.
Premier Wab Kinew must ask himself what is more important—the quality of education in Manitoba schools or stubbornly clinging to a mistaken policy.
The NDP government can either cling to a policy change that will lower the quality of future teachers, or it can learn from the mistakes of the previous NDP government and reverse course.
Hopefully, it makes the right choice.
Michael Zwaagstra is a public high school teacher and a senior fellow at the Frontier Centre for Public Policy.