The Newfoundland Government Should Better Understand Equalization
There are serious misunderstandings relative to equalization in the province’s announcement of its legal challenge.
For many years, the people of Newfoundland and Labrador and the other Atlantic Provinces have been told that there is a provision in the constitution that the federal government has an obligation to provide payments to ensure comparable programming of programming in all provinces at comparable levels of taxation.
This mantra, which underpins the Newfoundland Government announcement of its challenge, has been repeated so often that most of the province’s population believes it. It is not true.
The constitutional provision does not say that the federal government must make equalization payments at all. It says that the parties involved in the constitutional negotiations are “committed to the principle” of making equalization payments.
This means that any court hearing the province’s arguments must consider the meaning of the phrase “committed to the principle” and it is not clear how a court would interpret these words.
The many people concerned about the equalization program will argue that providing a program with much lower levels of funding than the current program is entirely constitutional because it would still demonstrate a substantial commitment to the principle of equalization.
They might also argue that if the framers of the constitution intended that the federal government had an unambiguous obligation to provide substantial funding, they would have said so. They didn’t.
The third of the many misconceptions in the government’s announcement is its intention to challenge the current equalization formula because it is unconstitutional. This is inappropriate for two reasons.
First, equalization is a federal government program. It would be nonsensical and have dramatic impacts on all government programming if it became accepted wisdom that different levels of government could not devise formulas and other arrangements relating to the funding associated with their programming.
Second, equalization formulas are not mentioned in the constitutional provision relating to equalization. It is difficult to see how the provincial government can argue, as it intends to do in this case, that anything related to a program is unconstitutional when the constitution doesn’t deal with the matter at all.