It was fully understood that the President of the United States may spend less than Congress allocates on certain projects if he deems the full funding amount unnecessary, and the power was recognized as existing and acceptable until Congress changed the rules unconstitutionally in 1974.
In 1974, in response to Watergate, the impending resignation of President Richard Nixon, and his unwillingness to spend federal funds in the manner Congress demanded, with the Impoundment Control Act, Congress used legislation to strip the President of the power.
Regardless of what one might think about the Presidential Power of Impoundment, the following facts surround it:
- It was recognized as a legitimate constitutional power of the President of the United States until 1974.
- In 1974 Congress used legislation to strip the President of the power that had been previously viewed as being constitutional.
The powers granted and retained by the executive branch, as previously stated, are “vested” in the President of the United States. Therefore, they may not be stripped, altered, or granted by legislation. Any change of powers granted to any branch of government requires a constitutional amendment. Therefore, the Impoundment Control Act of 1974 was unconstitutional. Congress had no power to “strip” the President of the power. While it is Congress’s job to use legislation to determine where money may be spent, Congressional control over how much of it is spent is not constitutionally granted, and in real world applications is unreasonable and could be disastrous.
In short, it is Congress’s job to legislate, and the President’s job to execute the laws of the United States. Due to the concept of the Separation of Powers, for Congress to dictate to the President how he may carry out his duties, and to restrict his authorities established by the Constitution with a piece of legislation is unconstitutional (which is another way of saying the 1974 law was illegal).
Which brings us back to President Trump, and his promise to use the Presidential Power of Impoundment when he returns to the Office of the President of the United States.
On the surface, he has every constitutional authority to do so. But, the question is, how will the establishment respond? From their point of view any reversal of the Impoundment Control Act of 1974 would need to either occur because Congress recognized their error so they repeal it with another piece of legislation, or the issue works its way to the courts. In order for the courts to look at it, the law would need to be defied, and a lawsuit would then need to be brought. Then, ultimately it would be up to the United States Supreme Court to determine if the law is unconstitutional or not. Yes, I realize what I am talking about is the unconstitutional practice of judicial review, and I am not suggesting that is what should happen; I am telling you that is probably what will happen.
With the current make up of the Supreme Court, I believe it would be a 5-4 decision, with the high court determining that the 1974 law was unconstitutional in the first place, therefore, invalidating the law and returning to the President of the United States the Power of Impoundment.
Just another reason why the leftwing Democrats are foaming at the mouth to stop Trump. He is intent upon unraveling their tyranny, and he’s willing to do it in ways that few people even realize exists.
My final tally? The Presidential Power of Impoundment is Constitutional, the 1974 Impoundment Control Act was unconstitutional, and the tyrants embedded inside our federal government will fight tooth and nail to stop the power of impoundment from ever becoming a thing again, unless of course a Democrat President wants to use it and a Republican Congress is shaking its finger saying, “No, you don’t.” Then, their argument will change, and they’ll pretend to be fans of the Constitution as long as they think it suits their tyrannical narrative.
By the way, Trump has used the power before. When he was President he limited how much of the COVID spending he used. This is not an issue he just suddenly came upon.