Should country specific trade surpluses and deficits be seen as positive, neutral, or negative?
What it does say is that the U.S./China trade deficit is unprecedented, and that there are optimistic, middle ground, and pessimistic opinions about it
- runs monthly net trade deficits;
- sees its cumulative net trade deficit grow to enormous levels; and,
- sees its Federal Government run large annual deficits to the detriment of its cumulative National Debt balance,
- the ongoing U.S. monthly and cumulative net trade deficits (which now stand average about U.S.$45 billion per month, and have consistently accumulated since 1973 to a current aggregate of about U.S.$8.5 trillion), are an important economic marker for me; and,
- each month the U.S. experiences a further net trade deficit, I think that is a month where the U.S. weakens economically against its trading partners.
- the currency of the country who has the trade deficit is received by its trading partner, which trading partner can then invest its ‘trade surplus’ back into the economy of the ‘trade deficit’ country. Note the operative word is ‘can’. Can does not mean the same thing as ‘will’; and,
- as a result of this reinvestment, the country with the trade deficit will see its trade deficit exactly matched by capital surpluses equal to the reinvestment – and ‘Bob will be your uncle’; or,
- that reinvestment by the ‘surplus country’ in the ‘deficit country’ will not take place, and the currency exchange rate of the ‘deficit country’ will drop; and,
- when the ‘trade deficit’ country’s exchange rate drops, its goods and services will become cheaper and eventually it will return to having a ‘trade surplus’.
- goes on to say that a country’s trade deficit (or surplus) with a specific country is meaningless. It refers to a single cross-country deficit as a ‘bilateral deficit’. This generally makes sense to me; but,
- doesn’t go so far as to say that a collective country trade deficit (or surplus) is meaningless. What it does say is that the U.S./China trade deficit is unprecedented, and that there are optimistic, middle ground, and pessimistic opinions about it.
- why would any country care if it lost its manufacturing jobs, and replaced them with service jobs or jobs that paid lower hourly rates; and,
- how is it that the United States has run consecutive monthly trade deficits in every quarter from 1978, and in every month since 1992 (and likely long before that – prior data not available), in circumstances where the recipients of U.S.$ have to some degree reinvested those dollars in U.S. treasury bills – yet the U.S. continues to run trade deficits, high Federal Government deficits, faces high unemployment rates, and is not replacing its manufacturing jobs in part due to technological change.
Read next: Trade Deficits And Surpluses Mean Nothing. It's Fiscal Failure That Wrecks Economies
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Ian R. Campbell, FCA, FCBV, is a recognized Canadian business valuation authority who shares his perspective about the economy, mining and the oil & gas industry on each trading day. Ian is also the founder of Stock Research Portal, which provides stock market data, analysis and research on over 1,600 Mining, Oil and Gas Companies listed on the Toronto and Venture Exchanges.
Note: The Commentary and information above is provided ‘AS IS’ and solely for informational purposes, not for trading purposes or advice.
